1938 New York gubernatorial election

none January 2025 September 2023 1938 New York gubernatorial election New York Flag of New York (1909–2020).svg presidential no 1936 New York gubernatorial election 1936 1942 New York gubernatorial election 1942 November 6, 1938 150x150px Herbert Lehman 1938 (cropped).jpg Herbert H. Lehman Democratic Party (United States) American Labor 2,391,286 49.59% Thomas E. Dewey color photograph (cropped).png Thomas E. Dewey Republican Party (United States) Independent Progressive 2,326,892 48.26% 1938 New York gubernatorial election results map by county.svg 300px County resultsLehman: #7996e2 50–60% #6674de 60–70% #584cde 70–80%Dewey: #e27f7f 50–60% #d75d5d 60–70% #d72f30 70–80% Governor Herbert H. Lehman Democratic Party (United States) Herbert H. Lehman Democratic Party (United States) The 1938 New York gubernatorial election was held on November 8, 1938. Incumbent Governor Herbert H. Lehman was narrowly re-elected to a fourth term in office over Manhattan District Attorney Thomas E. Dewey. Despite Dewey's defeat, the close race with Lehman elevated him to further prominence, positioning him as an early contender for the 1940 Republican presidential nomination. The 1938 election was the first election where the Governor of New York was elected to a four-year term, rather than a two-year term. Background Entering the 1938 campaign, the Democratic Party had elected three successive governors, Al Smith, Franklin D. Roosevelt and Herbert H. Lehman, continuously holding the office since 1918, with the exception of the two-year term of Republican Nathan Miller from 192123. Lehman, who was first elected in 1932 had won three terms by landslide margins as the Great Depression badly damaged Republican support in New York and many urban centers throughout the United States. One bright spot in the New York Republican Party was Thomas E. Dewey, a young Manhattan special prosecutor appointed by Lehman who had won national fame as a "gangbuster" for his successful arrests and prosecutions of organized crime figures, including Lucky Luciano and Lepke Buchalter.Smith 1982 207 His 1938 prosecution of former New York Stock Exchange president Richard Whitney for embezzlement also won him the support of financial reformers, raising him to the status of authentic national hero.Smith 1982 250 Dewey began laying the groundwork for a statewide campaign as early as summer 1936, when he met with Nassau County political boss J. Russell Sprague at the Long Island estate of Henry Root Stern, an attorney and treasurer of the state Republican Party. Sprague, who had led the New York delegation at that year's Republican National Convention. Following Robert Moses's disastrous performance in the 1934 election, Sprague was one of a coterie of young Republican leaders who sought to reform the party, including Edwin Jaeckle of Buffalo, W. Kingsland Macy of Suffolk County, and Kenneth Simpson of Manhattan. Dewey and Sprague discussed political affairs but made no firm promises.Smith 1982 21618 1937 Manhattan district attorney election In 1937, Samuel Seabury and other city reformers, including mayor Fiorello La Guardia and Adolf Berle, recruited Dewey to run for Manhattan District Attorney on a cross-party fusion ticket. Dewey had little interest in the position and repeatedly declined their nomination or placed grandiose conditions on acceptance, having already accepted a lucrative offer from John Foster Dulles to join his law firm, Sullivan & Cromwell. Nevertheless, supporters submitted his name and pressured him to join; shortly before the filing deadline, Dewey assented, under pressure to show that he was not, in his words, "a skunk [who] wouldn't run for an office I didn't want".Smith 1982 22831 Despite his initial reluctance, Dewey ran an aggressive and successful campaign. Starting as the distinct underdog in the overwhelmingly Democratic borough, he narrowed the odds to 6-to-5 by late September. Throughout October, Dewey hosted Sunday night radio talks where he recounted the details of his prosecutions. The addresses were wildly popular, and Dewey was ultimately elected by a margin of over 100,000 votes over the Tammany Hall candidate, greater than La Guardia's margin of victory in the borough.Smith 1982 23235Smith 1982 239 Republican nomination Candidates Thomas E. Dewey, District Attorney of New York County Declined George U. Harvey, Queens Borough President Campaign Having established a reputation as a popular prosecutor and successful campaigner, Dewey was the early front-runner for the Republican nomination in 1938, encouraged by national Republican leadership. Some political observers even suggested that he was a likely candidate for the presidency in 1940.Smith 1982 247 His political fortunes suffered a setback in the summer when judge Ferdinand Pecora declared a mistrial in his prosecution of Tammany Hall leader James Joseph Hines, but the Republican Party remained solidly behind him.Smith 1982 26162 (A second trial, with Charles Cooper Nott Jr. presiding, resulted in Hines's conviction on thirteen counts.) Ahead of the convention, Dewey ally George Z. Medalie oversaw a revision of the proposed party platform, liberalizing several provisions to better suit Dewey's campaign. As a result, Queens Borough President George U. Harvey, who believed Medalie would turn the party over to "the Communists", threatened to run an independent conservative campaign.Smith 1982 26162 Results The Republican state convention met on September 29 and nominated Dewey unanimously."DEWEY NOMINATED BY REPUBLICANS", The New York Times, September 30, 1938 (subscription required) In his acceptance speech, Dewey called for a new progressive Republican movement in the vein of former governors Theodore Roosevelt and Charles Evans Hughes and criticized obstructionism within his own party. Avoiding referencing Lehman, who had not yet agreed to run, by name, he charged, "any Democratic governor is, perforce, the good-will advertising, the front man, the window dressing for what is, in part at least, a thoroughly corrupt machine."Smith 1982 263 Radio reports of his speech were interrupted by news of the Munich Agreement.Smith 1982 264 Democratic nomination Candidates Herbert H. Lehman, incumbent Governor since 1933 (draft) Declined Ferdinand Pecora, justice of the New York Supreme Court and chief counsel to the United States Senate Committee on Banking and Currency Campaign Early indications suggested that Lehman had determined not to run for re-election to a fourth term, even before he was elected to a third. In July 1935, he invited judge Ferdinand Pecora, who had won fame for United States Senate investigations into Wall Street corruption, to lead a state grand jury indictment for racketeering, implicitly challenging Dewey's position as the face of criminal law in New York City. Pecora, who had run for District Attorney himself in 1933, was talked about as a potential successor to Lehman.Smith 1982 208 Lehman initially intended to run for U.S. Senate,Smith 1982 263 but under mounting pressure from his party to stave off the popular Dewey, he ultimately gave in to a draft effort on his behalf. The draft was led by James A. Farley, acting on behalf of President Roosevelt, who feared that a Dewey victory would jeopardize the state's support for the New Deal and Roosevelt's potential re-election to a third term.Smith 1982 264 On September 30, Lehman announced that he would run again.Smith 1982 264 Results The Democratic state convention met on October 1."LEHMAN IS DRAFTED FOR FOURTH TERM", The New York Times, October 1, 1938 (subscription required) Despite Lehman's pleas that he was not a candidate for nomination, he was successfully drafted as the nominee for a fourth term. The American Labor state convention met on October 3 at the Manhattan Opera House in New York City and nominated Lehman for governor. "LABORITES NAME LEHMAN, WAGNER", The New York Times, October 4, 1938 (subscription required)"LABOR NAMES MEAD AS SESSIONS CLOSE; Convention Also Nominates Post, O'Leary, Mrs. O'Day and Merritt to Fill Ticket", The New York Times, October 5, 1938 (subscription required) General election Candidates Thomas E. Dewey, District Attorney of New York County (Republican and Independent Progressive) Herbert H. Lehman, incumbent Governor since 1933 (Democratic and American Labor) Aaron M. Orange (Industrial Government) Norman Thomas, Presbyterian minister and perennial candidate (Socialist) Declined George U. Harvey, Queens Borough President (Independent Republican) The Socialist Party state convention met on October 1, and nominated again Norman Thomas for governor."SOCIALISTS ASSAIL 'DEALS' BY LABOR; ...THOMAS IS NOMINATED", The New York Times, October 2, 1938 (subscription required) The Socialist Labor Party changed its name to the "Industrial Government Party" and filed a petition to nominate Aaron M. Orange."INDUSTRIAL PARTY LISTS CANDIDATES", The New York Times, November 6, 1938 (subscription required) Following the American Labor nomination of Lehman, the Independent Progressive Party filed a petition to nominate a ticket led by Dewey, giving him a second ballot line to match Lehman."MAJOR PARTIES GET 2D LINES ON BALLOT", The New York Times, October 12, 1938 (subscription required) Campaign The Dewey campaign was among the first to make use of scientific political polling through a young George Gallup, whom Dewey befriended and cited as authoritative.Smith 1982 263 Dewey ran an active campaign in October and November,Smith 1982 266 mirroring his efforts in the 1937 race for District Attorney. He centered his message on state government competence and the power wielded by urban bosses outside Manhattan, such as Ed Flynn of the Bronx and Daniel O'Connell of Albany.Smith 1982 266 Rather than a traditional motorcar campaign through rural counties, Dewey utilized radio broadcasts in which he sought to address questions on his command of issues beyond crime.Smith 1982 26669 In his first broadcast, Dewey criticized Lehman directly for his management of state unemployment insurance and the supply of housing in the state. Other issues included civil service reform, public health, and electric rates. Seeking to gain independent and Democratic support, he openly referred to himself as a "New Deal Republican" and criticized Lehman as nothing more than "a branch manager in a chain store system of national politics."Smith 1982 26669 Oddsmakers revised Lehman's 4-to-1 lead down to 8-to-5 by mid-October, leaving the Dewey campaign optimistic of an upset.Smith 1982 26669 Despite these efforts, Dewey faced the challenge of unseating a popular incumbent with a personal reputation for sterling integrity. Several times in during the campaign, he walked back harsher criticisms of Lehman to avoid self-destructive guilt by association. Dewey also had the difficulty of balancing his criticisms of Democratic Party bosses with his own reliance on Republican machines in Buffalo and Long Island.Smith 1982 26669 Lehman had the support of the American Labor Party, most unions, and the Communist Party, and took a backseat in his own campaign, which was guided from Washington by President Roosevelt and his advisors. Roosevelt advised an approach which conceded Dewey's evident popularity, urging, "The best line that can be circulated in upstate New York, especially among Republican or Independent voters, is 'I propose to vote for Deweyto continue as District Attorney for the balance of his term.'"Smith 1982 27273 In a late effort to swing the large Jewish bloc in New York City, Roosevelt spoke obliquely of an anti-Semitic "whispering campaign", and Lehman seized on local Republican posters urging citizens to "Vote the American Way."Smith 1982 27273 thumb|right|x300px|In his November 4 address to the nation, President Franklin D. Roosevelt endorsed Lehman and harshly criticized Dewey and the Republican Party. On November 4, two days before the election, Roosevelt publicly endorsed Lehman and launched his final attack, criticizing Dewey as "yet to win his spurs" and comparing "old-time Republicans" to fascists and communists as a threat to democracy. Adapting Matthew 7:16, Roosevelt suggested that Dewey was a front for more insidious purposes: "By their promoters ye shall know them."Smith 1982 27273 Dewey responded at his closing rally, saying, "I stand before you accused of one crimeI was born in the twentieth century. To that I plead guilty. I am of the twentieth century. We look forward, not backward." Addressing the claim that he should be judged by his supporters, Dewey attacked the ties between the Democratic machine and organized crime, displaying a sheriff's commission given by Ed Flynn to mobster Dutch Schultz for the audience.Smith 1982 27273 Polling Poll sourceDate publishedMarginof errorThomas DeweyHerbert LehmanAmerican Institute of Public OpinionDEWEY AND LEHMAN FOUND EVEN IN RACE; Prosecutor Holding Ground Through Up-State Strength, Survey Indicates HIS TOTAL PUT AT 49.5% While That for Governor Is 50.5%--Roosevelt Address May Be Decisive Normal Error Is Put at 3 Per Cent Roosevelt Address Waited https://timesmachine.nytimes.com/timesmachine/1938/11/03/98206300.html 2025-08-09 The New York Times en 0362-4331November 3, 1938±3.0%49.5%50.5%American Institute of Public OpinionSTATE RIVALS EVEN IN A FINAL SURVEY; Closing Pre-election Study by Institute of Public Opinion Finds Result in Doubt WAGNER LEAD INDICATED His Vote Likely to Exceed That Cast for Head of Ticket, Dr. Gallup Asserts https://timesmachine.nytimes.com/timesmachine/1938/11/07/98207539.html 2025-08-10 The New York Times en 0362-4331November 6, 1938±3.0%49.8%50.2% Results The initial vote count was extremely close, but by midnight, Lehman clung to a 70,000 vote lead with only a handful of districts remaining. Dewey's 620,000-vote margin in upstate New York eclipsed even that of Herbert Hoover in 1928, and he lost only Albany County.Smith 1982 273 Lehman was only able to win reelection due to the votes he received on the American Labor ballot line. Dewey received more votes on the Republican ballot line than Lehman had on the Democratic ballot line.Murphy Paul 1974 Political Parties In American History, Volume 3, 1890-present G. P. Putnam's Sons 1938 New York gubernatorial election"LEHMAN PLURALITY OFFICIALLY 64,394; State Board Puts His Vote Finally at 2,391,286, With 2,326,892 for Dewey LABOR'S POLL AT 419,979 Blank, Void and Scattered Ballots Totaled 75,047; Poletti Won by 229,361", The New York Times, December 8, 1938 (subscription required)New York Red Book, 1939 Herbert H. Lehman Democratic Party (US) 1,971,307 40.88% 7.98 Herbert H. Lehman American Labor Party 419,979 8.71% 3.98 Herbert H. Lehman Total 2,391,286 49.59% 4.00 Thomas E. Dewey Republican Party (US) 2,302,505 47.75% 3.55 Thomas E. Dewey Ind. Progressive 24,387 0.51% N/A Thomas E. Dewey Total 2,326,892 48.26% N/A Norman Thomas Socialist Party USA 24,980 0.52% 1.05 Aaron M. Orange Industrial Government Party 3,516 0.07% N/A 75,047 1.56% 4,821,721 100.00% Aftermath Dewey's narrow defeat in the 1938 election nevertheless immediately established him as the leader of the New York Republican Party and front-runner for the 1940 Republican presidential nomination; William Allen White compared the loss to Abraham Lincoln's defeat in the 1858 Senate election against Stephen Douglass.Smith 1982 274 He quickly put together a campaign, but was ultimately defeated at the convention by a late surge of support for Wendell Willkie. Lehman opted not to stand for re-election in 1942 and was succeeded as governor by Dewey. Dewey went on to win the presidential nomination in 1944, losing to Roosevelt, and again in 1948, losing to Harry S. Truman in an historic upset. Notes References Sources Smith Richard Norton 1982 Thomas Dewey and His Times Simon and Schuster New York https://archive.org/details/thomasedeweyhist00smit/ See also New York gubernatorial elections New York state elections 1938 1938 New York Category:Thomas E. Dewey Category:November 1938 in the United States