2016 Dutch Ukraine–European Union Association Agreement referendum

2016 Dutch referendum December 2016 March 2021 Netherlands Are you for or against the Approval Act of the Association Agreement between the European Union and Ukraine? 2016 04 06 yes 1,571,874 2,509,395 32,344 4,151,613 12,862,658 For Against no Niederlande Referendum 2016.svg Results by municipality#24B14C For#DF0A24 Against Suspensory, non-binding referendum which has effect when a simple majority votes "Against" and turnout is at least 30%. An advisory referendum on the approval of the Ukraine–European Union Association Agreement was held in the Netherlands on 6 April 2016. The referendum question was: "Are you for or against the Approval Act of the Association Agreement between the European Union and Ukraine?"Visser Jeroen http://www.volkskrant.nl/binnenland/referendum-eu-verdrag-met-oekraine-is-6-april~a4173657/ Referendum EU-verdrag met Oekraïne is op 6 april Referendum for the EU treaty with Ukraine on 6 April nl De Volkskrant 29 October 2015 19 December 2016 live https://web.archive.org/web/20160204130138/http://www.volkskrant.nl/binnenland/referendum-eu-verdrag-met-oekraine-is-6-april~a4173657/ 4 February 2016 Bent u voor of tegen de wet tot goedkeuring van de Associatieovereenkomst tussen de Europese Unie en Oekraïne? Are you for or against the ratification of the Association Agreement between the European Union and Ukraine? With a turnout of 32.28%, the threshold for a valid referendum was met. 61% of the votes cast were against the Approval Act, and 38.2% in favour. This accounted for 19.5% of eligible voters voting against and 12.2% voting in favour. As the Act was rejected, the States General had to enact a follow-up law to either repeal the Act or put it into effect after all. The referendum was the first since the enactment of the Advisory Referendum Act (nl Wet raadgevend referendum) on 1 July 2015, Advisory Referendum Act in force https://www.kiesraad.nl/en/news/advisory-referendum-act-force https://web.archive.org/web/20160420124635/https://www.kiesraad.nl/en/news/advisory-referendum-act-force 2016-04-20 Dutch Electoral Council 30 October 2015 22 July 2015 with the Dutch tapping law referendum in 2018 to be the second.Nederland gaat stemmen over 'sleepwet' https://www.trouw.nl/democratie/nederland-gaat-stemmen-over-sleepwet-~a41048fb/ Trouw 1 November 2017 1 November 2017 The decision to hold a referendum was made after more than 427,000 valid requests were received within six weeks, more than the required number of 300,000 requests. The referendum was suspensory and non-binding, and following the rejection the Government had to propose "zo spoedig mogelijk" (en as soon as possible/at the earliest convenience) a new act to either gain parliamentary approval for either retraction of the approval act or for its entry into force. The government secured an additional agreement between the 28 Member States of the European Union addressing what were according to the government the concerns of the no-vote in December 2016. The additional agreement did not change the association agreement and neither Ukraine nor the European Union or Euratom were parties to the additional agreement. Following the approval of the additional agreement, a new law was passed approving the Association Agreement in May 2017,https://www.eerstekamer.nl/behandeling/20170614/publicatie_wet/document3/f=/vkf1bw0sscyb.pdf 236 - Wet van 31 mei 2017 tot regeling van de inwerkingtreding van de wet van 8 juli 2015, houdende goedkeuring van de op 27 juni 2014 te Brussel tot stand gekomen Associatieovereenkomst tussen de Europese Unie en de Europese Gemeenschap voor Atoomenergie en haar lidstaten, enerzijds, en Oekraïne, anderzijds (Stb. 2015, 315) 236 - Act of 31 May 2017 for the entry into force of the Law of 8 July 2015, approving the Association Agreement between the European Union and the European Atomic Energy Community and its Member States, of 27 June 2014, on the one part, and Ukraine, on the other part (Stb. 2015, 315) nl Senate (Eerste Kamer) of the Dutch Parliament 2017 26 August 2017 enabling the Netherlands to deposit its instrument of ratification on 15 June 2017.http://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/documents-publications/agreements-conventions/agreement/?aid=2014045 Agreement details 8 October 2017 Council of the European Union The association agreement entered into force on 1 September 2017. Background Advisory Referendum Act Referendums in the Netherlands In the Netherlands, before the Advisory Referendum Act's repeal in 2018, most types of primary laws could be subjected to a suspensory, non-binding referendum after royal assent and proclamation. The request procedure of a referendum consists of two stages. For the initial request, 10,000 requests have to be received within four weeks after proclamation of the law. After the requirements for this stage are met, 300,000 requests have to be received within six weeks after the completion of the initial request. Association Agreement Ukraine–European Union Association Agreement The Ukraine–European Union Association Agreement is a treaty between the European Union (EU), Euratom, their 28 Member States and Ukraine that establishes a political and economic association between the parties. The parties committed to co-operate and converge economic policy, legislation, and regulation across a broad range of areas, including equal rights for workers, steps towards visa-free movement of people, the exchange of information and staff in the area of justice, the modernisation of Ukraine's energy infrastructure, and access to the European Investment Bank. The parties committed to regular summit meetings, and meetings among ministers, other officials, and experts. The agreement furthermore establishes a Deep and Comprehensive Free Trade Area between the parties. The agreement enters into force upon ratification by all parties, but parts of the agreement are already applied provisionally. The Ukraine–European Union Association Agreement Approval Act was voted upon in the House of Representatives and Senate in 2015. People's Party for Freedom and Democracy (VVD), Labour Party (PvdA), Democrats 66 (D66), Christian Democratic Appeal (CDA), ChristianUnion (CU), GreenLeft (GL), Reformed Political Party (SGP), 50PLUS, Group Kuzu/Öztürk and independent MPs Houwers, Klein and Van Vliet voted in favour. Socialist Party, Party for Freedom, Groep Bontes/Van Klaveren and Party for the Animals voted against. The parties voted correspondingly in the Senate and the Independent Senate Group voted in favour. The Act received royal assent on 8 July 2015.https://www.eerstekamer.nl/wetsvoorstel/34116_goedkeuring 34.116: Goedkeuring Associatieovereenkomst tussen de Europese Unie en de Europese Gemeenschap voor Atoomenergie met Oekraïne 34.116: Approval of the Association Agreement between the European Union and the European Atomic Energy Community with Ukraine nl Senate (Eerste Kamer) of the Dutch Parliament 18 December 2014 27 August 2017 The Minister of Foreign Affairs published a decision in the Staatscourant on the same day, at which point the law became eligible for a referendum.https://zoek.officielebekendmakingen.nl/stcrt-2015-20054.html Referendabiliteitsbesluit inzake de wet houdende goedkeuring van de op 27 juni 2014 te Brussel tot stand gekomen Associatieovereenkomst tussen de Europese Unie en de Europese Gemeenschap voor Atoomenergie en haar lidstaten, enerzijds, en Oekraïne, anderzijds Referendum decision on the law approving the Association Agreement between the European Union and the European Atomic Energy Community and its Member States on the one part, and Ukraine on the other part, of 27 June 2014 nl zoek.officielebekendmakingen.nl 2015 Nr. 20054 10 July 2015 27 August 2017 Pending its entry into force, specific parts of the Agreement have been applied provisionally since 1 November 2014http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_STATEMENT-14-349_en.htm Joint Statement by the Presidents of Ukraine, the European Council and the European Commission on the occasion of the beginning of the provisional application of the Association Agreement 31 October 2014 7 February 2016 European Commission and 1 January 2016 (Deep and Comprehensive Free Trade Area).http://ec.europa.eu/trade/policy/countries-and-regions/countries/ukraine/ European Commission - Trade - Policy - Countries and regions - Ukraine European Commission 27 August 2017 According to Minister of Foreign Affairs Bert Koenders, this concerns about 70% of the Agreement, covering exclusive competence of the European Union.Obbema Fokke http://www.volkskrant.nl/politiek/nederlandse-staat-voor-de-rechter-om-oekraine-verdrag~a4238476/ Nederlandse staat voor de rechter om Oekraïne-verdrag Dutch State sued over Ukraine Treaty nl de Volkskrant 4 February 2016 7 February 2016 live https://web.archive.org/web/20160206083426/http://www.volkskrant.nl/politiek/nederlandse-staat-voor-de-rechter-om-oekraine-verdrag~a4238476/ 6 February 2016 Request GeenPeil, a cooperation between the website GeenStijl and the organisations Burgercomité EU and Forum voor Democratie, organised the campaign to collect the required signatures. They deployed a web application to collect, print and deliver the signatures to the Dutch Electoral Council (nl Kiesraad). Burgercomité EU is an organisation run by Pepijn van Houwelingen, Arjan van Dixhoorn, and Beata Supheert. Stage Required Received ValidPreliminary requestshttps://www.kiesraad.nl/nieuws/inleidend-verzoek-referendum-over-associatieverdrag-met-oekraïne-toegelaten Inleidend verzoek referendum over associatieverdrag met Oekraïne toegelaten Preliminary request referendum on the association agreement with Ukraine allowed nl 13 August 2015 Kiesraad dead https://web.archive.org/web/20150927185807/https://www.kiesraad.nl/nieuws/inleidend-verzoek-referendum-over-associatieverdrag-met-oekra%C3%AFne-toegelaten 27 September 2015 10,000 14,441 13,480 Definitive requests 300,000 472,849 427,939 On 14 October 2015, the Electoral Council held that both stages had been completed.http://nos.nl/artikel/2063040-geenpeil-referendum-gaat-door.html GeenPeil-referendum gaat door 14 October 2015 16 January 2016 NOS nl GeenPeil referendum proceeds An appeal was lodged with the adjudicative division of the Council of State, challenging the use of the web application to collect the signatures. On 26 October, the Council held that the claimant had no legal standing and dismissed the appeal.https://www.raadvanstate.nl/pers/persberichten/tekst-persbericht.html?id=785&summary_only=&category_id=8 Referendum Associatieovereenkomst Oekraïne kan doorgaan 26 October 2015 16 January 2016 Council of State nl Ukraine Association Agreement referendum can proceed The Referendum Committee announced on 29 October that the referendum would be held on 6 April 2016. Initial reactions In response to parliamentary questions, Prime Minister Mark Rutte said that he would await the course of the referendum and its result to decide how to move forward.Oekraïne-referendum dwingt kabinet tot scherpe EU-keuze NRC nl https://www.nrc.nl/nieuws/2015/10/21/oekraine-referendum-dwingt-kabinet-tot-scherpe-e-1549027-a160335 NRC Handelsblad 27 October 2015 21 October 2015 A majority in the House of Representatives, with the exception of VVD and D66, subsequently declared that they would respect the outcome of the referendum if the turnout exceeded 30% even if it is not binding.http://nos.nl/artikel/2071257-kamer-uitslag-referendum-oekraine-respecteren.html Kamer: uitslag referendum Oekraïne respecteren 25 November 2015 16 January 2016 NOS nl House: respect result Ukraine referendum A March 2016 survey found that 72% of Ukrainians wanted the Dutch to vote "yes", 13% wanted them to vote "no" and 15% were undecided.http://www.politico.eu/article/ukrainians-want-a-dutch-yes-in-eu-referendum/ Ukrainians want a Dutch Yes in EU referendum Cynthia Kroet Politico 29 March 2016 According to former Prime Minister and Minister for Foreign Affairs of Sweden Carl Bildt, "Were the European Union to turn its back on Ukraine and tear up the agreement – which is what the 'No' side in the Dutch debate wants – there is little doubt that this would encourage further Russian destabilisation of and aggression against Ukraine."http://www.ecfr.eu/article/Ukraine_The_case_for_voor5069 Ukraine: The case for 'voor' Carl Bildt Carl Bildt European Council on Foreign Relations 5 April 2016 The United States Department of State said that it is "in the interest of the United States, of the Netherlands, of the EU to help ensure that Ukraine becomes a democratic and economically stable country."https://www.voanews.com/a/dutch-cast-ballots-on-eu-ukraine-trade-deal/3271513.html Exit Polls: Dutch Reject EU-Ukraine Trade Deal VOA News 6 April 2016 27 August 2017 Campaign For a 'For' voteNo official party positionFor a 'Against' voteVVD PvdA CDA Democrats 66 GroenLinksChristianUnion SGP 50PLUSParty for the Animals Party for Freedom Socialist Party VoorNederland The government strategy for its campaign included the advice to call the Association Agreement a "cooperation agreement ("nl samenwerkingsverdrag") instead of an association agreement and to highlight trade as a key component of the agreement.Geeraedts Roel https://www.rtlnieuws.nl/nieuws/politiek/strategie-uitgelekt-zo-promoot-het-kabinet-een-ja-bij-het-oekraine-referendum Strategie uitgelekt: zo promoot het kabinet een 'ja' bij het Oekraïne-referendum Leaked strategy: that the government is promoting a 'yes' for the referendum on Ukraine nl RTL Nieuws 18 February 2016 27 August 2017 28 August 2017 https://web.archive.org/web/20170828063035/https://www.rtlnieuws.nl/nieuws/politiek/strategie-uitgelekt-zo-promoot-het-kabinet-een-ja-bij-het-oekraine-referendum dead According to Robert van Voren, proponents of the referendum were able to "accumulate four times the maximum campaign subsidy they were allowed to receive from the Dutch Government". He said that a businessman supporting the "no" campaign had been granted 50000 EUR and organisers of the referendum had received funds for campaigns "against", "in favour" and "neutral", but the latter two were "so cleverly written that they too evoked an "against" feeling".http://www.vdu.lt/en/dutch-referendum-a-painful-mistake/ Dutch referendum a painful mistake Robert van Voren Vytautas Magnus University 6 April 2016 27 August 2017 Open Society Foundations, a non-profit organization led by American billionaire George Soros, announced to the NOS that it would spend 200000 EUR on a "yes" campaign.Hekster Kysia https://nos.nl/artikel/2082091-amerikaanse-miljardair-sponsort-ja-campagne-oekraine-referendum.html Amerikaanse miljardair sponsort 'ja'-campagne Oekraïne-referendum American billionaire sponsors 'yes' campaign for Ukraine referendum nl nos.nl 22 January 2016 27 August 2017 In April 2016, the European Parliament began investigating the use of a European subsidy to buy a full-page advertisement in De Telegraaf to gather signatures in favour of holding the referendum.https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2016/04/06/eurocrats-investigate-deal-backed-by-nigel-farage-behind-dutch-r/ Eurocrats investigate deal backed by Nigel Farage behind Dutch referendum Senay Boztas Martin Banks The Telegraph 6 April 2016 27 August 2017 Nigel Farage said he had helped arrange financing for the advertisement. Opinion polls Date(s) conducted For Against Undecided Sample Conducted by 30 March–1 April 2016 25% 40% 13% undecided, 11% leaning for, 12% leaning against 27253 EenVandaaghttp://www.eenvandaag.nl/uploads/doc/RapportageApr.pdf 2 april 2016: Onderzoek: 'Het Oekraïne-referendum' 2 April 2016: Research: 'The Ukraine Referendum' nl EenVandaag 2 April 2016 19 December 2016 31 May 2016 https://web.archive.org/web/20160531145317/http://www.eenvandaag.nl/uploads/doc/RapportageApr.pdf dead 25–28 March 2016 36% 47% 18% 2382 I&O Researchhttps://ioresearch.nl/Portals/0/Rapport%20Oekraine-referendum%20eind%20maart%202016.pdf Rapport: Het referendum over de associatie-overeenkomst met Oekraïne, Slotpeiling I&O Research, 31 maart 2016 Report: The referendum on the association agreement with Ukraine, Slotpeiling I&O Research, 31 March 2016 nl I&O Research 31 March 2016 27 August 2017 10 February 2017 https://web.archive.org/web/20170210152802/http://www.ioresearch.nl/Portals/0/Rapport%20Oekraine-referendum%20eind%20maart%202016.pdf dead 13–20 March 2016 40% 60% N/A 3000+ https://home.noties.nl/peil/onderzoeksopzet/ Onderzoeksopzet 31 October 2016 Peil.nl De Hond Maurice nl Study design De weekpeiling, die wij op zondag publiceren, is minimaal op 3000 respondenten gebaseerd, maar vaak ook beduidend meer. [The weekly survey, which we publish on Sunday, is based on at least 3,000 respondents, though often significantly more.] 16 February 2016 https://web.archive.org/web/20160216141017/https://home.noties.nl/peil/onderzoeksopzet/ dead Peil.nlde Hond Maurice Maurice de Hond https://www.noties.nl/v/get.php?a=peil.nl&s=weekpoll&f=2016-03-20.pdf De Stemming van 20 maart 2016 The Vote at 20 March 2016 nl Peil.nl 20 March 2016 27 August 2017 4–7 March 2016 33% 44% 23% 2510 I&O Researchhttps://ioresearch.nl/Portals/0/RAPPORT%20Oekraine-referendum%20maart%202016.pdf Rapport: Het referendum over de associatie-overeenkomst met Oekraïne, Onderzoek I&O Research, Maart 2016 Report: The referendum on the association agreement with Ukraine, Investigation I&O Research, March 2016 nl I&O Research March 2016 27 August 2017 20 November 2017 https://web.archive.org/web/20171120192727/https://ioresearch.nl/Portals/0/RAPPORT%20Oekraine-referendum%20maart%202016.pdf dead 21–25 February 2016 19% 30% 22% undecided, 14% leaning for, 15% leaning against 29650 EenVandaaghttp://www.eenvandaag.nl/uploads/doc/HetOekrai%CC%88ne-referendum.pdf Het Oekraïne-referendum The Ukraine Referendum nl Opiniepanel.eenvandaag.nl EenVandaag 25 February 2016 27 August 2017 8 March 2016 https://web.archive.org/web/20160308081736/http://www.eenvandaag.nl/uploads/doc/HetOekrai%CC%88ne-referendum.pdf dead 29 January–8 February 2016 32% 38% 30% 2388 I&O Researchhttps://ioresearch.nl/Portals/0/RAPPORT%20Oekraine-referendum%20februari%202016.pdf Rapport: Het referendum over de associatie-overeenkomst met Oekraïne, Onderzoek I&O Research, Februari 2016 Report: The referendum on the association agreement with Ukraine, Investigation I&O Research, February 2016 nl I&O Research February 2016 27 August 2017 28 August 2017 https://web.archive.org/web/20170828011229/https://ioresearch.nl/Portals/0/RAPPORT%20Oekraine-referendum%20februari%202016.pdf dead 1–7 February 2016 40% 60% N/A 3000+ Peil.nl https://www.noties.nl/v/get.php?a=peil.nl&s=weekpoll&f=20160207.pdf De Stemming van 7 februari 2016 7 February 2016 7 February 2016 Peil.nl De Hond Maurice nl 12–21 January 2016 31% 38% 31% 2550 I&O Researchhttps://ioresearch.nl/Portals/0/RAPPORT%20Het%20referendum%20over%20de%20associatie-overeenkomst%20met%20Oekraine%20IenO%20en%20UT.pdf Rapport: Het referendum over de associatie-overeenkomst met Oekraïne, Onderzoek I&O Research i.s.m. Universiteit Twente, December 2015 / januari 2016 Report: The referendum on the association agreement with Ukraine, Investigation I&O Research i.s.m. University of Twente, December 2015 / January 2016 nl I&O Research January 2016 27 August 2017 19 October 2016 https://web.archive.org/web/20161019234104/http://www.ioresearch.nl/Portals/0/RAPPORT%20Het%20referendum%20over%20de%20associatie-overeenkomst%20met%20Oekraine%20IenO%20en%20UT.pdf dead 18–28 December 2015 13% 51% 13% leaning for, 23% leaning against 27151 EenVandaaghttp://www.eenvandaag.nl/uploads/doc/RapportageReferendum.pdf 13 april 2016: Onderzoek: 'Het Oekraïne-referendum' 13 April 2016: Research: 'The Ukraine Referendum' nl EenVandaag 13 January 2016 19 December 2016 https://web.archive.org/web/20160308083244/http://www.eenvandaag.nl/uploads/doc/RapportageReferendum.pdf 8 March 2016 dead 3–20 December 2015 25% 41% 34% 3490 I&O Research Results Referendums under the Advisory Referendum Act were not binding. To be valid, a turnout of at least 30% of eligible voters was required and a simple majority (over 50%) defined the result.Barker Alex http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/d2d9aab8-65a8-11e5-a28b-50226830d644.html Netherlands faces possible referendum on Ukraine Financial Times 28 September 2015 27 August 2017 subscription In the event of a valid vote against the Act, the States General had to enact a new law either to repeal the Act or to provide for its entry into force. As long as the Approval Act has not entered into force, the instrument of ratification cannot be deposited by the Netherlands, as a result of which the agreement as a whole cannot enter into force.April 2016 The referendum was valid: the turnout was roughly 32.3%, and the treaty was rejected with 61% of voters voting against it, and 38.2% of voters voting for it.http://bnonews.com/news/index.php/news/id4041 Dutch voters reject EU treaty with Ukraine in non-binding referendum BNO News 6 April 2016 27 August 2017 https://web.archive.org/web/20170828014356/http://bnonews.com/news/index.php/news/id4041 28 August 2017 deadhttp://www.independent.ie/world-news/dutch-voters-reject-euukraine-deal-in-referendum-34606535.html Dutch voters 'reject EU-Ukraine deal in referendum' Press Association 7 April 2016 27 August 2017 Independent.iehttps://www.kiesraad.nl/nieuws/uitslag-referendum-associatieovereenkomst-met-oekra%C3%AFne https://web.archive.org/web/20160412162613/https://www.kiesraad.nl/nieuws/uitslag-referendum-associatieovereenkomst-met-oekra%C3%AFne 12 April 2016 Uitslag referendum Associatieovereenkomst met Oekraïne 12 April 2016 12 April 2016 De Kiesraad nl Result of the referendum EU treaty with Ukraine On 18 November 2016, Stichting KiezersOnderzoek Nederland, an independent academic organisation,http://www.dpes.nl/nl/nationaal-kiezersonderzoek/organisatie Organisatie StichtingKiezersonderzoek Nederland nl Organisation 26 November 2016 28 February 2017 https://web.archive.org/web/20170228003529/http://www.dpes.nl/nl/nationaal-kiezersonderzoek/organisatie dead published a report on the referendum results, which had been anticipated by the Dutch Government. Amongst other things, the organisation investigated the opponents' motives for voting against. According to the report, for the largest group of "against" voters (34.1%), corruption in Ukraine was the predominant motive. For the second-largest group, it was the 'fear of Ukraine membership of the EU'.Heck Wilmer https://www.nrc.nl/nieuws/2016/11/18/rapport-referendum-oekraine-is-niet-wat-rutte-had-gehoopt-5355661-a1532530 Rapport referendum Oekraïne is niet wat Rutte had gehoopt Report on Ukraine referendum is not what Rutte had hoped nl NRC 18 November 2016 27 August 2017 Met 34,1 procent is dat laatste onderwerp, corruptie in Oekraïne, veruit het meest genoemde motief onder de tegenstemmers. … [De] tweede zorg onder de tegenstemmers [is] de angst dat Oekraïne lid wordt van de EU. [At 34,1 percent, this last topic, corruption in Ukraine, is by far the most-often mentioned motive among "against" voters. The second worry among "against" voters, is the fear that Ukraine becomes a member of the EU.] A 2023 study found that euroskepticism or support for the EU was a strong predictor of how individuals voted in the referendum. Views on the EU were a stronger predictor of vote choice than concerns about Russia.2023 EU-sentiment predicts the 2016 Dutch referendum vote on the EU's association with Ukraine better than concerns about Russia or national discontent https://doi.org/10.1177/14651165231157612 European Union Politics 10.1177/14651165231157612 Abts Koen Etienne Tom Kutiyski Yordan Krouwel André 24 3 494–515 free 1871.1/59f739a2-8083-461d-b224-7e3faeb6d1a7 free Reactions Dutch Government Rutte responded that if the turnout was above 30 percent with such a large margin of victory for the "No" camp, then his sense was that ratification could not simply go ahead. The leader of the coalition Labour Party, Diederik Samsom, also felt that they could not ratify the treaty in this fashion.Escritt Thomas Deutsch Anthony http://uk.reuters.com/article/uk-netherlands-eu-idUKKCN0X3001 https://web.archive.org/web/20160406010925/http://uk.reuters.com/article/uk-netherlands-eu-idUKKCN0X3001 dead 6 April 2016 Dutch 'No' to Ukraine pact forces government rethink Reuters Amsterdam 6 April 2016 27 August 2017 The Dutch Government campaigned in favour of the agreement. Rutte said that it is good for the European Union and the Netherlands and not to be seen as a first step to Ukraine's EU membership, saying: "We are a trading nation. We live by free trade agreements and Ukraine is another example of this [...] People who are inclined to vote No think it's a first step to EU membership. It has nothing to do with accession."Dutch PM to campaign for Yes in EU-Ukraine referendum https://euobserver.com/foreign/131752 EUobserver 9 January 2016 8 January 2016 Rettman Andrew Academia Sijbren de Jong, writing in the EU Observer, said that the referendum was "curious": "It is a treaty of the kind the EU has with many countries: think Moldova, Jordan, Chile, and many others. [...] Interestingly, not a soul raised a finger back when these agreements were negotiated."https://euobserver.com/opinion/132908 Why the Dutch referendum on Ukraine is a joke Sijbren de Jong EU Observer 4 April 2016 19 December 2016 Writing for the Kyiv Post, Jan Germen Janmaat and Taras Kuzio reported that the treaty's opponents were using "stereotypes, half-truths and demeaning propaganda" against Ukraine.https://www.kyivpost.com/article/opinion/op-ed/jan-germen-janmaat-and-taras-kuzio-the-no-camp-in-netherlands-resorts-to-stereotypes-half-truths-and-demeaning-propaganda-411422.html The no camp in Netherlands resorts to stereotypes, half-truths and demeaning propaganda Taras Kuzio Taras Kuzio Jan Germen Janmaat Kyiv Post 6 April 2016 19 December 2016 Janmaat and Kuzio said that the no campaign "repeats Russian disinformation" and De Jong said that their arguments show "immediate parallels" with the Russian state media's portrayal of Ukraine. Andreas Umland called the result of the referendum "a propaganda triumph for Putin", "a lasting embarrassment for the Dutch nation", and "a public humiliation of millions of Ukrainians who, during the last years, have been fighting both peacefully and, on eastern Ukrainian battlefields, with arms for their national liberation and European integration."https://www.kyivpost.com/article/opinion/op-ed/andreas-umland-gratitude-for-mass-murder-411508.html Gratitude for mass murder Andreas Umland Andreas Umland Kyiv Post 7 April 2016 19 December 2016 Opponents of the agreement, such as writer Leon de Winter, said that it goes well beyond the trade agreement and includes also political and military support.http://www.telegraaf.nl/opinie/25132144/__Handelsverdrag_is_je_reinste_bedrog__.html Handelsverdrag is je reinste bedrog Trade treaty is the purest deceit nl de Winter Leon Leon de Winter De Telegraaf 3 February 2016 19 December 2016 subscriptionhttps://www.nrc.nl/nieuws/2016/04/07/alles-wat-je-moet-weten-over-het-oekraine-referendum-a1405153 Alles wat je moet weten over het Oekraïne-referendum op 6 april Everything you need to know about Ukraine referendum on April 6 nl Heck Wilmer NRC Handelsblad 5 April 2016 19 December 2016 The Party for the Animals said that support for Ukraine was "problematic", calling it "the most corrupt country on the European continent".https://www.partijvoordedieren.nl/zeg-nee-tegen-het-associatieverdrag-met-oekraine Zeg NEE tegen het associatieverdrag met Oekraïne Say NO to the Association Agreement with Ukraine nl Party for the Animals 19 December 2016 https://web.archive.org/web/20160423081952/https://www.partijvoordedieren.nl/zeg-nee-tegen-het-associatieverdrag-met-oekraine 23 April 2016 dead Ukrainian authorities According to Ukrainian President Petro Poroshenko, "the true goal of the Dutch referendum [was] to attack Europe's unity".Poroshenko: True goal of Dutch referendum to attack Europe's unity https://www.kyivpost.com/article/content/ukraine-politics/poroshenko-true-goal-of-dutch-referendum-to-attack-europes-unity-411517.html Kyiv Post 7 April 2016 19 December 2016 subscription This view was echoed by Anne Applebaum in Slate who cited the Dutch referendum as a good example of how Russian influence actually works in a Western European election, though she did not know how much the referendum was influenced by Russian propaganda.Applebaum Anne Anne Applebaum How Much Trouble Is Russia Causing in Europe? Too much, based on the results of a Dutch referendum about Ukraine http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/foreigners/2016/04/the_dutch_referendum_on_ukraine_shows_how_russia_is_influencing_europeans.html Slate 8 April 2016 20 December 2016 The European Commission proposed granting visa-free travel to Ukrainians despite the Dutch referendum vote against an EU-Ukraine agreement, with an anonymous "senior EU source" saying that "It may look as if we're ignoring the Dutch voters, but we have to keep our word to Ukraine".Taylor Paul https://www.reuters.com/article/us-netherlands-eu-ukraine-idUSKCN0X70SJ EU to propose visa-free travel for Ukraine despite Dutch vote: source Reuters 11 April 2016 12 April 2016 live https://web.archive.org/web/20160411134556/https://www.reuters.com/article/us-netherlands-eu-ukraine-idUSKCN0X70SJ 11 April 2016 On 24 November 2016, it was announced that a ninety-day visa free period might eventually be granted for Ukrainian citizens with a biometric passport for the Schengen area.https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-38095930 Ukraine citizens to get visa-free travel to EU BBC.com 24 November 2016 20 December 2016 Dutch press In an interview with the Burgercomité EU, the members admitted they didn't really care about Ukraine at all, but are against the political system of the EU.https://www.nrc.nl/nieuws/2016/03/31/oekraine-kan-ons-niets-schelen-1606419-a969298 Oekraïne kan ons niets schelen NRC 31 March 2016 nrc.nl nl Heck Wilmer After the referendum journalists started investigating the people of this organization and found out founding member Pepijn van Houwelingen had published a book under a pseudonym. NRC Handelsblad, De Dagelijkse Standaard and De Groene Amsterdammer raised questions about the political motives of van Houwelingen, since, according to them, the book romanticized fascism, repression and nationalism.https://www.nrc.nl/nieuws/2016/04/30/de-machtsfantasie-van-een-referendumactivist-1616421-a1353669 De machtsfantasie van een referendumactivist NRC 30 April 2016 nrc.nl nl Stokmans Derk Heck Wilmer http://www.dagelijksestandaard.nl/2016/04/organisator-oekrainereferendum-blijkt-te-dromen-over-fascisme-en-onderdrukking/ Organisator Oekraïnereferendum blijkt te dromen over fascisme en onderdrukking 30 April 2016 dagelijksestandaard.nl nl 6 May 2016 25 March 2021 https://web.archive.org/web/20210325103603/https://www.dagelijksestandaard.nl/2016/04/organisator-oekrainereferendum-blijkt-te-dromen-over-fascisme-en-onderdrukking/ deadFogteloo Margreet https://www.groene.nl/artikel/met-open-vizier Met open vizier? With open sight? nl groene.nl 4 May 2016 27 August 2017 Aftermath The Dutch government established several main points that in their opinion were the reason for the vote against the treaty. The government negotiated with the other EU member states about an addendum and clarification to the treaty to remove these objections.Peeperkorn Marc https://www.volkskrant.nl/politiek/rutte-vindt-toch-nog-geitenpaadje-oekrainedeal-tekst-met-verklaring-ligt-klaar~a4434325/ Rutte vindt toch nog 'geitenpaadje' Oekraïnedeal: tekst met verklaring ligt klaar Rutte still finds a "goat track" for the Ukraine deal: text of statement is ready nl Volkskrant.nl 15 December 2016 26 August 2017 It was concluded in December 2016 by all EU member states with the following points:http://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/meetings/european-council/2016/12/15-euco-conclusions-ukraine/ European Council Conclusions on Ukraine (15 December 2016) Brussels European Council consilium.europa.eu 15 December 2016 26 August 2017 no establishment of EU candidate status to Ukraine through this agreement no guarantees of military aid or security guarantees to Ukraine no freedom of Ukrainians to reside or work in the EU no increases of bilateral financial support to Ukraine based on the agreement the goal to work towards reduction of corruption in Ukraine, and (as a last resort) to suspend the Agreement if not enough progress is made. The addendum was approved by the EU member states, but not by the European Union or Ukraine. Afterwards, a new ratification act was submitted to parliament. In February 2017, the House of Representatives passed the agreement with 89 votes in favour and 55 against.https://www.tweedekamer.nl/kamerstukken/wetsvoorstellen/detail?id=2017Z01353&dossier=34669 Wetsvoorstel 34669: Regeling van de inwerkingtreding van de wet van 8 juli 2015, houdende goedkeuring van de op 27 juni 2014 te Brussel tot stand gekomen Associatieovereenkomst tussen de Europese Unie en de Europese Gemeenschap voor Atoomenergie en haar lidstaten, enerzijds, en Oekraïne, anderzijds (Stb. 2015, 315) Bill 34669: Arrangement of entry into force of the Law of 8 July 2015, approving the Association Agreement between the European Union and the European Atomic Energy Community and its Member States, on the one part, and the Ukraine, of 27 June 2014, on the other part ( Stb. 2015, 315) nl House of Representatives of the Netherlands 27 January 2017 26 August 2017 In May 2017 the Senate passed the agreement with 50 votes in favour and 25 against. This meant that the agreement was accepted by the Dutch parliament.https://www.eerstekamer.nl/wetsvoorstel/34669_regeling_inwerkingtreding?zoekrol=vgh5mt4dsdk1 34.669 - Regeling inwerkingtreding van de goedkeuring Associatieovereenkomst tussen de Europese Unie en de Europese Gemeenschap voor Atoomenergie met Oekraïne 34.669 - Scheme implementation of the endorsement of the Association Agreement between the European Union and the European Atomic Energy Community with Ukraine nl Senate (Eerste Kamer) of the Dutch Parliament 28 July 2015 26 August 2017 The Netherlands subsequently deposited its instrument of ratification in June 2017, thus finalising its ratification period. The addendum entered into force upon the deposit of the instrument of ratification. After the deposit, the European Union and Euratom did so as well, allowing for entry into force of the agreement on 1 September 2017. The referendum was not an issue in the Dutch general election in March 2017, except for Forum for Democracy which used the issue in the campaign and that went from zero to two seats in the parliament and supported a "no" vote.Hubert Smeets https://www.nrc.nl/nieuws/2017/03/17/hoe-het-anti-kiev-kamp-alsnog-dramatisch-verloor-7406886-a1550746 Hoe het anti-Kiev-kamp alsnog dramatisch verloor NRC How the anti-Kiev camp still lost dramatically nl nrc.nl 17 March 2017 27 August 2017 See also Malaysia Airlines Flight 17 Netherlands–Ukraine relations Ukraine–European Union relations Referendums in the Netherlands References 30em External links Category:Referendums in the Netherlands Category:Euroscepticism in the Netherlands Netherlands Ukraine Category:Netherlands–Ukraine relations Category:Referendums related to the European Union Category:Netherlands and the European Union Category:Ukraine–European Union relations Ukraine Netherlands