1948 Australian rents and prices referendum

Unsuccessful Australian constitutional amendment vote October 2021October 2021 1948 Australian rents and prices referendum Do you approve of the proposed law for the alteration of the Constitution entitled —"Constitution Alteration (Rents and Prices) 1947" ? 1948 05 29 y Australia 1,793,712 2,618,183 64,106 4,783,887 Amendment Failed The Constitution Alteration (Rents and Prices) Bill 1947,https://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/download/legislation/billshistorical/HBILL194648V100059/upload_binary/059 - CONSTITUTION ALTERATION (RENTS AND PRICES) Bill 1947.pdf Constitution Alteration (Rents and Prices) Bill 1944 (Cth). was an unsuccessful proposal to alter the Australian Constitution to give the Commonwealth power to make laws with respect to rents and prices. It was put to voters for approval in an Australian referendum held on 29 May 1948. Question Do you approve of the proposed law for the alteration of the Constitution entitled 'Constitution Alteration (Rents and Prices) 1947'? Proposed Changes to the Constitution The proposal was to insert into section 51 that the Parliament have power to make laws with respect to:(xivA.) Rents and prices (including charges); Background Control over prices was one of the 14 post-war powers that had been rejected in the 1944 referendum.Handbook The proposal was put forward and supported by the Chifley Labor government and was opposed by the Liberal–Country Coalition. For The Prime Minister Ben Chifley summed up his arguments for the proposal in the Sydney Morning Herald on 28 May 1948 as:First, because rising prices threaten the value of wages or salaries, and of savings, and undermine the stability of the economy. Secondly, because price control by six controlling authorities in the States will not work - the choice is Commonwealth control or no control. Thirdly, because the Government can be relied on to administer price control sanely, to decentralise as much as possible, and to remove controls as supplies become adequate. Fourthly, because a stable Australia will be a maximum help to Britain and to a world struggling back to economic health.https://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article18072780 The case for "Yes" Ben Chifley Ben Chifley The Sydney Morning Herald 28 May 1948 2021-10-19 2 Trove Against The Leader of the Opposition, Robert Menzies summed up his arguments against the proposal as:First is that the Federal Government's campaign of fear, with its predictions of chaos and of soaring rents and prices if the referendum is defeated, has been thoroughly and rightly discounted from one end of Australia to another. Secondly, the State Governments, including, of course, the Governments in those States which still have Labour Administrations, have all acknowledged that the powers of the States are ample, and have declared their willingness to undertake control, if necessary, when the Commonwealth retires from the price and rent fixing field. The third point, now generally recognised, is that this is in no sense a referendum on the desirability or otherwise of controls. ... This is a referendum simply to determine whether the controls involved should eventually revert to the States or whether they should be given to Canberra for ever. ... everyone in the Commonwealth is doubtless aware now that whatever the result of Saturday's vote, the present Federal controls will continue for some considerable period.https://nla.gov.au/nla.news-article18072777 The case for "No" Robert Menzies Robert Menzies The Sydney Morning Herald 28 May 1948 2021-10-19 2 Trove Results + ResultHandbook State Electoral roll Ballots issued For Against Informal Vote % Vote % New South Wales 1,880,779 1,762,091 723,183 41.66 1,012,639 58.34 26,269 Victoria 1,351,853 1,270,037 559,361 44.63 693,937 55.37 16,739 Queensland 669,555 617,678 187,955 30.80 422,236 69.20 7,487 South Australia 422,809 402,778 167,171 42.15 229,438 57.85 6,169 Western Australia 301,223 278,282 105,605 38.59 168,088 61.41 4,589 Tasmania 157,668 145,135 50,437 35.45 91,845 64.55 2,853 Armed forcesArmed forces totals are also included in their respective states.   11,905 6,557   5,213   135 Total for Commonwealth 4,783,887 4,476,001 1,793,712 40.66 2,618,183 59.34 64,106 Results Obtained majority in no state and an overall minority of 824,471 votes. Not carried Discussion This was the second of 11 referendums (2021 10 y) that failed to achieve a majority in any state. Power to control prices was sought for a third time in the 1973 referendum.Handbook See also Politics of Australia History of Australia Referendums in Australia References Handbook Handbook of the 44th Parliament (2014) http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo/search/display/display.w3p;query=Id%3A%22handbook%2Fnewhandbook%2F2014-10-31%2F0049%22 Part 5 - Referendums and Plebiscites - Referendum results Parliamentary Library of Australia Category:1948 referendums 1948 Referendum Category:May 1948 in Australia