17-animal inheritance puzzle

Mathematical puzzle ly March 2023 March 2023 thumb|upright=1.5|17 indivisible camels|alt=Refer to caption The 17-animal inheritance puzzle is a mathematical puzzle involving unequal but fair allocation of indivisible goods, usually stated in terms of inheritance of a number of large animals (17 camels, 17 horses, 17 elephants, etc.) which must be divided in some stated proportion among a number of beneficiaries. It is a common example of an apportionment problem. Despite often being framed as a puzzle, it is more an anecdote about a curious calculation than a problem with a clear mathematical solution.sesiano Beyond recreational mathematics and mathematics education, the story has been repeated as a parable with varied metaphorical meanings. Although an ancient origin for the puzzle has often been claimed, it has not been documented. Instead, a version of the puzzle can be traced back to the works of Mulla Muhammad Mahdi Naraqi, an 18th-century Iranian philosopher. It entered the western recreational mathematics literature in the late 19th century. Several mathematicians have formulated different generalizations of the puzzle to numbers other than 17. Statement According to the statement of the puzzle, a man dies leaving 17 camels (or other animals) to his three sons, to be divided in the following proportions: the eldest son should inherit 2 of the man's property, the middle son should inherit 3, and the youngest son should inherit 9. How should they divide the camels, noting that only a whole live camel has value?stockmeyer Solution thumb|upright=1.5|Solution to the 17-animal inheritance puzzle|alt=Refer to caption As usually stated, to solve the puzzle, the three sons ask for the help of another man, often a priest, judge, or other local official. This man solves the puzzle in the following way: he lends the three sons his own camel, so that there are now 18 camels to be divided. That leaves nine camels for the eldest son, six camels for the middle son, and two camels for the youngest son, in the proportions demanded for the inheritance. These 17 camels leave one camel left over, which the judge takes back as his own.stockmeyer This is possible as the sum of the fractions is less than one: 2 + 3 + 9 = 17 18. Some sources point out an additional feature of this solution: each son is satisfied, because he receives more camels than his originally-stated inheritance. The eldest son was originally promised only 8 1 2 camels, but receives nine; the middle son was promised 5 2 3, but receives six; and the youngest was promised 1 8 9, but receives two.bss History Similar problems of unequal division go back to ancient times, but without the twist of the loan and return of the extra camel. For instance, the Rhind Mathematical Papyrus features a problem in which many loaves of bread are to be divided in four different specified proportions.stockmeyer finkel The 17 animals puzzle can be seen as an example of a "completion to unity" problem, of a type found in other examples on this papyrus, in which a set of fractions adding to less than one should be completed, by adding more fractions, to make their total come out to exactly one.anne Another similar case, involving fractional inheritance in the Roman empire, appears in the writings of Publius Juventius Celsus, attributed to a case decided by Salvius Julianus.cajori smith The problems of fairly subdividing indivisible elements into specified proportions, seen in these inheritance problems, also arise when allocating seats in electoral systems based on proportional representation.carerd Many similar problems of division into fractions are known from mathematics in the medieval Islamic world,sesiano finkel ageron but "it does not seem that the story of the 17 camels is part of classical Arab-Islamic mathematics".ageron Supposed origins of the problem in the works of al-Khwarizmi, Fibonacci or Tartaglia also cannot be verified.nasbar A "legendary tale" attributes it to 16th-century Mughal Empire minister Birbal.naranan The earliest documented appearance of the puzzle found by Pierre Ageron, using 17 camels, appears in the work of 18th-century Shiite Iranian philosopher Mulla Muhammad Mahdi Naraqi.ageron By 1850 it had already entered circulation in America, through a travelogue of Mesopotamia published by James Phillips Fletcher.fletcher maxwin It appeared in The Mathematical Monthly in 1859,nasbar tmm and a version with 17 elephants and a claimed Chinese origin was included in Hanky Panky: A Book of Conjuring Tricks (London, 1872), edited by William Henry Cremer but often attributed to Wiljalba Frikell or Henry Llewellyn Williams.stockmeyer nasbar The same puzzle subsequently appeared in the late 19th and early 20th centuries in the works of Henry Dudeney, Sam Loyd,stockmeyer Édouard Lucas,ageron Professor Hoffmann,hoffmann and Émile Fourrey,fourrey among others.morrell white drummond wensmi A version with 17 horses circulated as folklore in mid-20th-century America.browne A variant of the story has been told with 11 camels, to be divided into 2, 4, and 6.vv seibert Another variant of the puzzle appears in the book The Man Who Counted, a mathematical puzzle book originally published in Portuguese by Júlio César de Mello e Souza in 1938. This version starts with 35 camels, to be divided in the same proportions as in the 17-camel version. After the hero of the story lends a camel, and the 36 camels are divided among the three brothers, two are left over: one to be returned to the hero, and another given to him as a reward for his cleverness. The endnotes to the English translation of the book cite the 17-camel version of the problem to the works of Fourrey and Gaston Boucheny (1939).nasbar Beyond recreational mathematics, the story has been used as the basis for school mathematics lessons,bss coyle as a parable with varied morals in religion, law, economics, and politics,drummond anspach chadosh ost teubner and even as a lay-explanation for catalysis in chemistry.swann Generalizations Paul Stockmeyer, a computer scientist, defines a class of similar puzzles for any number of animals, with the property that can be written as a sum of distinct divisors of . In this case, one obtains a puzzle in which the fractions into which the animals should be divided are Because the numbers have been chosen to divide , all of these fractions simplify to unit fractions. When combined with the judge's share of the animals, , they produce an Egyptian fraction representation of the number one.stockmeyer The numbers of camels that can be used as the basis for such a puzzle (that is, numbers that can be represented as sums of distinct divisors of ) form the integer sequence 1.6 1, 3, 5, 7, 11, 15, 17, 19, 23, 27, 29, 31, 35, 39, 41, ...oeis S. Naranan, an Indian physicist, seeks a more restricted class of generalized puzzles, with only three terms, and with equal to the least common multiple of the denominators of the three unit fractions, finding only seven possible triples of fractions that meet these conditions.naranan Brazilian researchers Márcio Luís Ferreira Nascimento and Luiz Barco generalize the problem further, as in the variation with 35 camels, to instances in which more than one camel may be lent and the number returned may be larger than the number lent.nasbar See also The monkey and the coconuts, a more complicated fair-division puzzle References Ageron Pierre 1 Revue d'histoire des mathématiques fr 1–41 Le partage des dix-sept chameaux et autres arithmétiques attributes à l'immam 'Alî: Mouvance et circulation de récits de la tradition musulmane chiite https://ageron.users.lmno.cnrs.fr/17chameaux.pdf 19 2013 2023-03-24 2023-03-24 https://web.archive.org/web/20230324160528/https://ageron.users.lmno.cnrs.fr/17chameaux.pdf live ; see in particular pp. 13–14. Anne Premchand 10.1080/07468342.1998.11973958 4 The College Mathematics Journal 2687685 1648474 296–300 Egyptian fractions and the inheritance problem 29 1998 Anspach C. L. December 1939 2 Christian Education 41173250 96–102 Eternal values 23 Browne Ray B. Fall 1961 3 Midwest Folklore 4317919 155–160 Riddles from Tippecanoe County, Indiana 11 Ben-Chaim David Shalitin Yechiel Stupel Moshe February 2019 10.1017/mag.2019.2 556 The Mathematical Gazette 12–19 Historical mathematical problems suitable for classroom activities 103 86506133 Cajori Florian Florian Cajori 79–80 MacMillan and Co. A History of Mathematics https://archive.org/details/ahistorymathema01cajogoog/page/n99 1894 Çarkoğlu Ali Erdoğan Emre 10.1017/s0896634600003046 New Perspectives on Turkey 97–124 Fairness in the apportionment of seats in the Turkish legislature: is there room for improvement? 19 1998 148547260 Chodosh Hiram E. March 2008 10.1017/s2071832200006428 3 German Law Journal 251–283 The eighteenth camel: mediating mediation reform in India 9 141042869 Coyle Stephen November 2000 5 Mathematics in School 30215451 40 Fractions give me the hump 29 Rambling Recollections II Sir Henry Drummond Wolff Henry Drummond Wolff 1908 MacMillan and Co. London 56 A Parsee inspiration https://archive.org/details/ramblingrecollec02wolf/page/56 Finkel Joshua Hebrew Union College Annual 23506151 109–149 A mathematical conundrum in the Ugaritic Keret poem 26 1955 Fletcher James Phillips 206 Lea & Blanchard Notes from Nineveh: And Travels in Mesopotamia, Assyria and Syria https://archive.org/details/notesfromnineve00fletgoog/page/n213 1850 Fourrey Émile Curieux partages https://archive.org/details/rcrationsari00fouruoft/page/158 fr Paris 159 Librairie Nony Récréations arithmétiques 1899 Professor Hoffmann Professor Hoffmann Puzzles Old and New Frederick Warne and Co. 1893 London No. XI—An Unmanageable Legacy 147 https://archive.org/details/puzzlesoldnew00hoff/page/146; solution, pp. 191–192 Maxham Ephraim Wing Daniel Ripley October 24, 1850 14 Waterville, Maine The Eastern Mail 3 A Wise Judge https://digitalcommons.colby.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1168&context=eastern_mail 4 2023-03-24 2023-03-24 https://web.archive.org/web/20230324205142/https://digitalcommons.colby.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1168&context=eastern_mail live Morrell E. W. February 1897 10.2307/2970050 2 The American Mathematical Monthly 2970050 61 Problems for solution: arithmetic, no. 76 4 Naranan S. 5 Mathematics Magazine 2688266 1572070 276–278 An "elephantine" equation 46 1973 10.2307/2688266 Nascimento Márcio Luís Ferreira Barco Luiz September 2016 10.1080/17513472.2016.1221211 1–4 Journal of Mathematics and the Arts 35–43 The man who loved to count and the incredible story of the 35 camels https://repositorio.ufba.br/handle/ri/21774 10 54030575 2023-03-25 2023-03-25 https://web.archive.org/web/20230325012037/https://repositorio.ufba.br/handle/ri/21774 live A085493 Numbers k having partitions into distinct divisors of k + 1 cs2 Ost F. July 2011 10.1093/jnlids/idr003 2 Journal of International Dispute Settlement 333–351 The twelfth camel, or the economics of justice 2 Seibert Thomas M. The arguments of a judge December 1987 10.1515/9783110869170 119–122 De Gruyter Argumentation: Analysis and Practices 978-3-11-013027-0 Récréations Mathématiques au Moyen Âge fr Jacques Sesiano Lausanne Presses Polytechniques et Universitaires Romandes 2014 Le partage des chameaux 198–200 https://books.google.com/books?id=JEkGDQAAQBAJ&pg=PA198 2023-03-25 2023-03-25 https://web.archive.org/web/20230325205324/https://books.google.com/books?id=JEkGDQAAQBAJ&pg=PA198 live Smith David Eugene David Eugene Smith 10.2307/2972701 2 The American Mathematical Monthly 1518704 64–71 On the origin of certain typical problems 24 1917 2972701 Stockmeyer Paul K. September 2013 10.4169/mathhorizons.21.1.8 1 Math Horizons 10.4169/mathhorizons.21.1.8 3313765 8–11 Of camels, inheritance, and unit fractions 21 125145732 Swann W. F. G. William Francis Gray Swann July 1931 1 The Scientific Monthly 15070 5–10 Greetings of the American Physical Society 33 1931SciMo..33....5S Teubner Gunther Nelken David Priban Jiri Alienating justice: on the social surplus value of the twelfth camel https://ssrn.com/abstract=876958 London 21–44 Ashgate Law's New Boundaries: Consequences of Lega Autopoiesis 2001 2023-03-26 2023-07-08 https://web.archive.org/web/20230708135100/https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=876958 live The Mathematical Monthly 362 https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=hvd.32044102937240&view=1up&seq=398 Problem Notes and queries 1 11 August 1859 2023-03-25 2023-03-25 https://web.archive.org/web/20230325023803/https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=hvd.32044102937240&view=1up&seq=398 live Van Vleck J. H. January 1929 10.1021/cr60020a006 4 Chemical Reviews 467–507 The new quantum mechanics 5 Wentworth George Smith David Eugene David Eugene Smith 467 Ginn and Company Wentworth–Smith Mathematical Series Complete Arithmetic https://archive.org/details/completearithmet00went/page/466 1909 White William F. Puzzle of the camels https://archive.org/details/scrapbookofeleme00whitrich/page/192 193 The Open Court Publishing Company A Scrap-Book of Elementary Mathematics: Notes, Recreations, Essays 1908 Category:Fair item allocation Category:Mathematical puzzles