1928–29 Cardiff City F.C. season

Welsh football club season August 2020 Cardiff City 1928–29 Fred Stewart Walter Parker Division One 22nd FA Cup Third round Welsh Cup Finalists Hughie Ferguson (14) Hughie Ferguson (15) 14,880 20,174 (v Burnley, 1 September 1928) 5,738 (v Blackburn Rovers, 4 May 1929) _whitecollar _whiteline 0000FF 0000FF 0000FF FFFFFF 0000FF 1927–28 1929–30 The 1928–29 season was the 28th season of competitive football played by Cardiff City F.C. and the team's eighth consecutive year in the First Division of the Football League. Having finished in sixth place the previous year, the team had a significantly worse season after being plagued by injuries to several first team players. Despite conceding the fewest goals in the league, they were relegated from the First Division after finishing bottom. In the FA Cup Cardiff suffered similar struggles and were knocked out in the third round after losing 6–1 to Aston Villa. As of August 2020, the loss remains the club's worst defeat in the competition. In the Welsh Cup, they reached the final for the third consecutive season but were defeated 3–0 by Connah's Quay & Shotton. Hughie Ferguson was the club's top goalscorer for the third consecutive season, netting 15 times in all competitions. He achieved this despite missing nearly half of the campaign due to injury, playing in only 23 games. John Jennings made the most appearances of any player and was ever present during the season, playing in every senior team fixture. Background Cardiff City were competing in the First Division of the Football League for the eighth consecutive season.http://fchd.info/CARDIFFC.HTM Cardiff City Football Club History Database 22 August 2020 They finished in sixth position the previous season, despite being the third lowest scoring side in the First Division and being in the top ten for goals conceded during the campaign.https://www.11v11.com/league-tables/league-division-one/06-may-1928/ League Division One end of season table for 1927–28 season 11v11.com AFS Enterprises 22 August 2020 An economic downturn in the South Wales region that had begun two years previously continued to impact the club as attendance figures dropped significantly and required the sale of several first team players during the campaign, including two members of the 1927 FA Cup Final winning team, Sam Irving and Ernie Curtis.Leighton 2010 129 Still limited by a lack of funds, manager Fred Stewart had signed several players from non-league sides during the final months of the previous season, such as Matt Robinson, Tom Helsby, William Roberts and Francis Harris, who formed part of the first team for the 1928–29 season.Shepherd 2002 30 In an attempt to improve the club's goalscoring record, Stan Davies was signed from fellow First Division side Birmingham. Two others, Leslie Jones and Emlyn John also arrived from nearby Welsh sides Aberdare Athletic and Mid Rhondda respectively.Leighton 2010 132 Cardiff had undertaken a tour of Denmark at the end of the previous season and had shown interest in signing Creutz Jensen, who had impressed the club's delegation in one match. The board secured his signing on a free transfer but he was denied a work permit by the Ministry of Labour and the move, which would have seen him become the first foreign player in the club's history, subsequently collapsed.https://www.walesonline.co.uk/sport/football/football-news/cardiff-city-files-12-weirdest-9562493 The Cardiff City files: The 12 weirdest things you never knew happened behind the scenes at the Bluebirds WalesOnline Media Wales Tucker Steve 1 July 2015 21 August 2020 At boardroom level, Walter Parker was reappointed as chairman having taken a year out in which his position had been held by Watkins J. Williams.Lloyd 1999 109 The club had invested a significant portion of its profits from winning the 1927 FA Cup in constructing a new roof for the 18,000 capacity Grange End Stand at Ninian Park. The new stand was due to be opened for the club's first home game of the season on 1 September 1928.Saunders 2013 74 First Division August–December Cardiff began the season with an away match against Newcastle United on 25 August 1928. Hughie Ferguson, the club's top goalscorer for the previous two campaigns, opened his account from the penalty spot as the match ended in a 1–1 draw. The club's first home match of the season was against Burnley on 1 September and was preceded by an opening ceremony for the newly constructed roof above the Grange End Stand which was led by the Lord Mayor of Cardiff, Arthur John Howell. The Cardiff City Miscellany Richard Shepherd Pitch Books 2007 978-1-905411-04-7 23 Ferguson continued his strong start to the season by scoring five times, with Len Davies adding a brace, during a 7–0 victory. As of August 2020, the result remains the team's largest win in the top tier while Ferguson's tally of five is the most scored by a Cardiff player in a league match, tied with Walter Robbins and Jim Henderson.Hayes 2006 221 Their first defeat of the season followed a week later as they lost 2–0 to Derby County. Ferguson scored a brace on 10 September during a 3–2 win over West Ham United, with Billy Thirlaway also scoring his first of the season. Stan Davies scored his first goal for the club following his transfer in the next match, but was unable to stop the side losing 3–1 to Sheffield United. Ferguson continued his scoring streak with a goal in a 1–1 draw in the reverse fixture with West Ham on 17 September and another during a 4–0 win over Bury five days later, taking his tally to ten goals in the opening seven games of the campaign to help his side to fifth place.https://go.gale.com/ps/retrieve.do?tabID=Newspapers&resultListType=RESULT_LIST&searchResultsType=SingleTab&searchType=AdvancedSearchForm&currentPosition=17&docId=GALE%7CCS101261112&docType=Sports+news&sort=Pub+Date+Forward+Chron&contentSegment=ZTMA-MOD1&prodId=TTDA&contentSet=GALE%7CCS101261112&searchId=R2&userGroupName=wikipedia&inPS=true&ps=1&cp=17 subscription Association Football The Times 6 24 September 1928 21 August 2020 The Times Digital Archive However, Cardiff's positive start quickly ended as the first team encountered an injury crisis. Already without Tom Watson since the start of the season, Cardiff lost both Ferguson and Jimmy Nelson to injury in their next two games, defeats to Aston Villa and Leicester City. Nelson's injury ultimately ended his season, as he appeared only two more times that year, while Ferguson was plagued by injury, missing more than half of the remaining matches. Cardiff gained their second away point of the season in a 1–1 draw with Manchester United on 13 October with George McLachlan scoring his first goal of the season. With Ferguson absent, Cardiff struggled in front of goal, losing back-to-back fixtures 1–0 against Sunderland and Sheffield Wednesday and dropping into the bottom six in the table despite possessing one of the best defensive records in the division.https://go.gale.com/ps/retrieve.do?tabID=Newspapers&resultListType=RESULT_LIST&searchResultsType=SingleTab&hitCount=12137&searchType=AdvancedSearchForm&currentPosition=6&docId=GALE%7CCS118562646&docType=Sports+news&sort=Pub+Date+Forward+Chron&contentSegment=ZTMA-MOD1&prodId=TTDA&pageNum=1&contentSet=GALE%7CCS118562646&searchId=R3&userGroupName=wikipedia&inPS=true subscription League Results and Tables The Times 7 22 October 1928 21 August 2020 The Times Digital Archive Stewart experimented with William Shaw, Francis Harris and Stan Davies in Ferguson's place but all were quickly replaced. Ferguson returned in a 1–1 draw with Arsenal, with Tom Sloan scoring his first league goal for the club. However, Sloan also succumbed to injury after the game and, like Nelson, would appear in only two further league matches for the rest of the season. Ferguson appeared in two further games, a 1–0 defeat to reigning league champions Everton and a goalless draw with Huddersfield Town, before again dropping out of the first team due to injury. Cardiff ended November with a 1–1 draw with Manchester City. Potter Smith scored only the side's second goal in their previous six matches. On 1 December, Cardiff were beaten 4–1 by Birmingham but, in their following match, they secured their first victory in nearly three months by beating fellow strugglers Portsmouth. Albert Miles scored the only goal of the game to give Cardiff their first win in 11 matches to move them out of the relegation zone.https://go.gale.com/ps/retrieve.do?tabID=Newspapers&resultListType=RESULT_LIST&searchResultsType=SingleTab&hitCount=12137&searchType=AdvancedSearchForm&currentPosition=24&docId=GALE%7CCS101654410&docType=Sports+news&sort=Pub+Date+Forward+Chron&contentSegment=ZTMA-MOD1&prodId=TTDA&pageNum=2&contentSet=GALE%7CCS101654410&searchId=R3&userGroupName=wikipedia&inPS=true subscription League Results and Tables The Times 6 10 December 1928 21 August 2020 The Times Digital Archive Teenager Walter Robbins, who made his professional debut against Portsmouth, scored his first senior goal to earn his side a 1–1 draw with Bolton Wanderers on 15 December but two further defeats on 22 and 25 December against Blackburn Rovers and Leeds United left Cardiff in the relegation zone again.https://go.gale.com/ps/retrieve.do?tabID=Newspapers&resultListType=RESULT_LIST&searchResultsType=SingleTab&hitCount=12137&searchType=AdvancedSearchForm&currentPosition=38&docId=GALE%7CCS84877208&docType=Sports+news&sort=Pub+Date+Forward+Chron&contentSegment=ZTMA-MOD1&prodId=TTDA&pageNum=2&contentSet=GALE%7CCS84877208&searchId=R3&userGroupName=wikipedia&inPS=true subscription League Results and Tables The Times 5 24 December 1928 21 August 2020 The Times Digital Archive Thirlaway and Harry Wake provided some respite for the side to end the calendar year as the pair scored both goals in a 2–1 victory in the reverse fixture against Leeds and a 2–0 win over Newcastle on 29 December. January–May Cardiff were defeated by Bolton and Burnley in the first week of 1929, but were boosted by Ferguson's first goals since September in a 3–0 win over Derby on 19 January. He had returned from injury for the second time shortly after the Christmas period and scored a brace in the win, with McLachlan adding the other. However, the club's lack of proficiency in front of goal continued to be a problem as they recorded a goalless draw with Sheffield United on 26 January, failing to score in three of their four matches in the month. Ferguson added another goal on 2 February, but his side fell to a 4–1 defeat against fellow strugglers Bury.https://go.gale.com/ps/retrieve.do?tabID=Newspapers&resultListType=RESULT_LIST&searchResultsType=SingleTab&hitCount=12097&searchType=AdvancedSearchForm&currentPosition=24&docId=GALE%7CCS118038596&docType=Sports+news&sort=Pub+Date+Forward+Chron&contentSegment=ZTMA-MOD1&prodId=TTDA&pageNum=2&contentSet=GALE%7CCS118038596&searchId=R2&userGroupName=wikipedia&inPS=true subscription League Results and Tables The Times 7 4 February 1929 21 August 2020 The Times Digital Archive Cardiff recorded consecutive 2–0 defeats against Aston Villa and Leicester in mid-February before securing their first point of the month with a 2–2 draw with Manchester United. Ferguson scored his 14th league goal of the campaign during the match, but it proved to be his final appearance of the season as he finally succumbed to the injuries that had plagued him during the campaign. The match was also the final game at the club for the other goalscorer, Stan Davies. He scored his second of the campaign, but departed soon after to take up a position as player-manager at Rotherham United. Stewart made two signings during this period to try to improve the club's fortunes, adding former England international Frank Moss from Aston Villa and Jimmy Munro from St. Johnstone, the leading goalscorer in the Scottish First Division at the time.Leighton 2010 133 Despite beginning March with a 1–0 loss against Sunderland, Cardiff's hopes were raised when they defeated league leaders Sheffield Wednesday 3–1 at Ninian Park on 8 March. Thirlaway opened the scoring with his fifth league goal of the season before Len Davies and Fred Warren secured victory. However, the result was followed by three consecutive defeats to Arsenal, Liverpool and Everton, with only one goal scored in the process. A draw with Huddersfield on 30 March and a second defeat to Liverpool the following day left Cardiff bottom of the First Division table, two points from safety and having played two games more than the side in 20th place.https://go.gale.com/ps/retrieve.do?tabID=Newspapers&resultListType=RESULT_LIST&searchResultsType=SingleTab&hitCount=12097&searchType=AdvancedSearchForm&currentPosition=45&docId=GALE%7CCS101785731&docType=Sports+news&sort=Pub+Date+Forward+Chron&contentSegment=ZTMA-MOD1&prodId=TTDA&pageNum=3&contentSet=GALE%7CCS101785731&searchId=R2&userGroupName=wikipedia&inPS=true subscription Association Football The Times 6 3 April 1929 21 August 2020 The Times Digital Archive New signing Munro scored his first goal for the club against Manchester City on 6 April, but the side fell to a 3–1 defeat at Ninian Park. A goalless draw with Birmingham left the club's fate in the hands of the teams above them, with 20th place Burnley needing only a point from their remaining five fixtures to confirm Cardiff's relegation.https://go.gale.com/ps/retrieve.do?tabID=Newspapers&resultListType=RESULT_LIST&searchResultsType=SingleTab&hitCount=12097&searchType=AdvancedSearchForm&currentPosition=51&docId=GALE%7CCS84615311&docType=Sports+news&sort=Pub+Date+Forward+Chron&contentSegment=ZTMA-MOD1&prodId=TTDA&pageNum=3&contentSet=GALE%7CCS84615311&searchId=R2&userGroupName=wikipedia&inPS=true subscription League Results and Tables The Times 5 15 April 1929 21 August 2020 The Times Digital Archive Cardiff were officially relegated on 20 April as they failed to beat relegation rivals Portsmouth, drawing 1–1 at Ninian Park with a goal from Munro. Their final match of the season was another 1–1 draw at Ninian Park, this time against Blackburn Rovers with only 5,738 spectators attending. Unusually, Cardiff finished bottom of the First Division table despite conceding fewer goals than any other team in the league. However, their defensive record was outweighed by their poor offence as they possessed easily the league's lowest scoring side, scoring 13 fewer goals than the next-lowest scoring team. In total, they scored only 43 goals in 42 league games, failing to score in 17 matches during the campaign. Partial league table 1928–29 Football League#First Division First Division y CAR https://www.11v11.com/league-tables/league-division-one/10-may-1929/ League Division One end of season table for 1928—29 season 11v11.com AFS Enterprises 25 August 2020 Match results Key In result column, Cardiff City's score shown first H = Home match A = Away match pen. = Penalty kick o.g. = Own goal Results Cardiff City 100 Years of Professional Football Terry Grandin Vertical Editions 219 2010 978-1-904091-45-5 DateOpponentsResultGoalscorersAttendance 25 August 1928 Newcastle United (A) 1–1 Ferguson (pen) 36,964 1 September 1928 Burnley (H) 7–0 Ferguson (5), L. Davies (2) 20,174 8 September 1928 Derby County (A) 0–2 20,462 10 September 1928 West Ham United (H) 3–2 Ferguson (2), Thirlaway 17,189 15 September 1928 Sheffield United (A) 1–3 S. Davies 24,207 17 September 1928 West Ham United (A) 1–1 Ferguson 13,750 22 September 1928 Bury (H) 4–0 L. Davies (2), Ferguson, Thirlaway 18,739 29 September 1928 Aston Villa (A) 0–1 30,190 6 October 1928 Leicester City (H) 1–2 Harris 19,477 13 October 1928 Manchester United (A) 1–1 McLachlan 26,010 20 October 1928 Sunderland (H) 0–1 15,361 27 October 1928 Sheffield Wednesday (A) 0–1 20,116 3 November 1928 Arsenal (H) 1–1 Sloan 18,757 10 November 1928 Everton (A) 0–1 25,994 17 November 1928 Huddersfield Town (H) 0–0 13,845 24 November 1928 Manchester City (A) 1–1 Smith 18,778 1 December 1928 Birmingham (H) 1–4 Thirlaway 13,691 8 December 1928 Portsmouth (A) 1–0 Miles 19,649 15 December 1928 Bolton Wanderers (H) 1–1 Robbins 11,286 22 December 1928 Blackburn Rovers (A) 0–2 11,040 25 December 1928 Leeds United (A) 0–3 28,188 26 December 1928 Leeds United (H) 2–1 Thirlaway, Wake 20,439 29 December 1928 Newcastle United (H) 2–0 Thirlaway, Wake 12,254 1 January 1929 Bolton Wanderers (A) 0–1 33,651 5 January 1929 Burnley (A) 0–3 10,966 19 January 1929 Derby County (H) 3–0 Ferguson (2), McLachlan 14,647 26 January 1929 Sheffield United (H) 0–0 17,334 2 February 1929 Bury (A) 1–4 Ferguson 9,954 9 February 1929 Aston Villa (H) 0–2 15,978 21 February 1929 Leicester City (A) 0–2 12,938 23 February 1929 Manchester United (H) 2–2 Ferguson, S. Davies 13,070 2 March 1929 Sunderland (A) 0–1 21,546 9 March 1929 Sheffield Wednesday (H) 3–1 Thirlaway, L. Davies, Warren 18,636 16 March 1929 Arsenal (A) 1–2 L. Davies 28,393 23 March 1929 Everton (H) 0–2 14,681 29 March 1929 Liverpool (A) 0–2 30,927 30 March 1929 Huddersfield Town (A) 1–1 L. Davies 13,332 1 April 1929 Liverpool (H) 1–2 Wake 16,849 6 April 1929 Manchester City (H) 1–3 Munro 11,392 13 April 1929 Birmingham (A) 0–0 12,997 20 April 1929 Portsmouth (H) 1–1 Munro 10,834 4 May 1929 Blackburn Rovers (H) 1–1 Harris 5,738 Cup matches FA Cup Cardiff entered the FA Cup in the third round and were drawn against fellow First Division side Aston Villa. In the match, Cardiff suffered a heavy 6–1 defeat with Billy Hardy scoring their goal. As of August 2020, the result remains Cardiff's biggest defeat in the competition.Leighton 2010 134 Match results Key In result column, Cardiff City's score shown first H = Home match A = Away match N = Neutral venue pen. = Penalty kick o.g. = Own goal Results DateRoundOpponentsResultGoalscorersAttendance 12 January 1929 Three Aston Villa (A) 1–6 Hardy 51,242 Welsh Cup Holders of the competition for the second consecutive year, Cardiff began their Welsh Cup campaign by overcoming Lovell's Athletic in the fifth round. Ferguson, Harris and Len Davies each scored to secure a 3–1 victory. In the sixth round, Munro scored the only goal of the game to defeat Newport County. In a repeat of the previous year, Cardiff defeated Rhyl in the semi-final to reach their third consecutive final.Saunders 2013 75 In the final, they met Connah's Quay & Shotton and were considered the overwhelming favourites in the media for the match. However, the opposition side caused a major upset by winning 3–0, a defeat which Christian Saunders describes in his 2013 book From the Ashes – The Real Story of Cardiff City Football Club as "one of the biggest shocks the... tournament ever produced". Match results Key In result column, Cardiff City's score shown first H = Home match A = Away match N = Neutral venue pen. = Penalty kick o.g. = Own goal Results DateRoundOpponentsResultGoalscorersAttendance 27 February 1929 Five Lovell's Athletic (H) 3–1 Ferguson, Harris, L. Davies 5,000 25 March 1929 Six Newport County (A) 1–0 Munro 4,000 25 April 1929 Semi-final Rhyl (A) 2–1 Blackburn, L. Davies 7,000 1 May 1929 Final Connah's Quay & Shotton (N) 0–3 10,000 Player details During the course of the season, Stewart used a significantly higher number of players due to injury and form, with 30 making at least one appearance during the campaign. John Jennings made more appearances than any other player as he was ever present, playing in all 42 league matches and 5 cup fixtures. Prior to this season, Jennings had normally been considered a reserve player, but the long-term injuries to Nelson and Watson led to him becoming a regular. Keenor and Thirlaway were the only other players to make more than 40 appearances, while four others, Joe Hillier, Jimmy McGrath, Robinson and Watson made a single appearance during the campaign. For the third consecutive season, Ferguson was the club's top goalscorer. He scored 15 goals in all competitions, 14 in the league and 1 in the Welsh Cup, despite missing nearly half of the club's matches during the campaign due to injury. Len Davies was the only other player to reach double figures during the season, scoring 10 times. The club's poor goalscoring record was reflected in the fact that, including Ferguson and Len Davies, only four players scored more than twice during the season. Player statistics PlayerPositionFirst DivisionFA CupWelsh CupTotalAppsGoalsAppsGoalsAppsGoalsAppsGoalsGeorge Blackburn footballer, born 1899 HB2400031271Len Davies FW27800423110Stan Davies footballer FW1420010152Tom Farquharson GK3500040390Hughie Ferguson FW201400312315Tommy Hampson footballer GK60100070Billy Hardy footballer HB2201110241Francis Harris footballer FW1320011143Thomas Helsby DF1301010150Joe Hillier GK10000010John Jennings footballer HB4201040470Emlyn John DF20000020Fred Keenor DF3601040410Frank Matson FW60002080Jimmy McGrath HB10000010George McLachlan FW3321030372Albert Miles footballer FW2110003 1Frank Moss footballer, born 1895 HB90000090Jimmy Munro footballer, born 1905 FW1120011123Jimmy Nelson footballer DF1100000110Walter Robbins FW71100081William Roberts footballer, born 1907 DF2100040250Matt Robinson footballer, born 1907 FW10000010William Shaw footballer FW20000020Tom Sloan footballer, born 1900 HB1510000151Potter Smith FW1410000141Billy Thirlaway FW3751040425Harry Wake HB1731030213Fred Warren Fred Warren (footballer, born 1907) HB1911010211Tom Watson footballer, born 1900 DF10000010 FW = Forward, HB = Halfback, GK = Goalkeeper, DF = Defender Sources: Aftermath Relegation dropped Cardiff into the Second Division for the first time since their inaugural season in the Football League. The club's decreasing finances and the income drop of falling out of the First Division led to a number of departures before the following season. Top scorer Ferguson returned to Scotland with Dundee. He suffered a loss of form and further injuries on his return and endured considerable barracking from the club's supporters. Less than 8 months after departing Cardiff, he committed suicide in Dundee's home stadium after a training session at the age of 34.Saunders 2013 76 Jennings, Hillier and Warren all left the club in January 1930 in a triple transfer to Middlesbrough while McLachlan also departed to join Manchester United.Saunders 2013 77 In a club programme at the end of the season, Keenor bemoaned Cardiff's injury problems and noted that the season represented "a testing time of true support, both morally and financially."Lloyd 1999 110 The club struggled on their return to the Second Division and were relegated again two years later to the Third Division South. References Specific Bibliography The Who's Who of Cardiff City Dean Hayes Breedon Books 2006 978-1-85983-462-6 James Leighton Fred Keenor – The Man Who Never Gave Up 2010 Derby Books Publishing Company Derby 978-1-85983-828-0 https://archive.org/details/fredkeenormanwho0000leig/page/24 C'mon City! A Hundred Years of the Bluebirds Grahame Lloyd Seren Books 1999 1854112716 From the Ashes – The Real Story of Cardiff City Football Club Saunders Christian Llygad Gwalch Cyf 2013 9781845242138 The Definitive: Cardiff City F.C. Richard Shepherd SoccerData Publications Nottingham 2002 1-899468-17-X Cardiff City F.C. Category:Cardiff City F.C. seasons Car