411 REFERENCE · Wikipedia
2012 Illinois judicial elections
Reference material by Wikipedia contributors. This retains its source identity and is not 411 news reporting.
none
January 2025
September 2023
2012 Illinois judicial elections presidential no 2010 Illinois judicial elections 2010 2014 Illinois judicial elections 2014 November 6, 2012
The 2012 Illinois judicial elections consisted of both partisan and retention elections, including those one seat of the Supreme Court of Illinois for ten seats in the Illinois Appellate Court.https://ballotpedia.org/Illinois_judicial_elections,_2012 Illinois judicial elections, 2012 Ballotpedia en 2021-05-13 Primary elections were held on March 20, 2012, and general elections were held on November 6, 2012. These elections were part of the 2012 Illinois elections.
3
Supreme Court of Illinois
Justices of the Supreme Court of Illinois are elected by district. One seat held a partisan election, while another held a retention election.
The court has seven seats total separated into five districts. The first district, representing Cook County, contains three seats, making it a multi-member district, while other four districts are single-member districts.Illinois Constitution - Article VI http://www.ilga.gov/commission/lrb/con6.htm www.ilga.gov Illinois General Assembly 22 March 2020 Justices hold ten year terms.
1st district
In October 2010, Democrat Mary Jane Theis was appointed by the Supreme Court to fill the vacancy left by the retirement of justice Thomas R. Fitzgerald.JUSTICE MARY JANE THEIS TO BECOME NEWEST MEMBER OF THE ILLINOIS SUPREME COURT https://courts.illinois.gov/Media/PressRel/2010/102510_2.pdf Illinois Courts 13 May 2021 25 October 2010 Theis successfully ran for election to fill this seat for a full term.
Democratic primary
Supreme Court of Illinois 1st district Democratic primaryElection Results https://www.elections.il.gov/ElectionOperations/ElectionVoteTotals.aspx www.elections.il.gov Illinois State Board of Elections 13 May 2021 22 February 2020 https://web.archive.org/web/20200222093629/https://www.elections.il.gov/ElectionOperations/ElectionVoteTotals.aspx dead
Democratic Party (United States)
Mary Jane Theis (incumbent)
193,863
48.37
Democratic Party (United States)
Joy Cunningham
91,639
22.87
Democratic Party (United States)
Aurelia Marie Pucinski
85,554
21.35
Democratic Party (United States)
Thomas W. Flannigan
29,708
7.41
537,239
100
Republican primary
No candidates ran in the primary for the Republican nomination. Republicans ultimately nominated James Gerard Riley.
General election
Supreme Court of Illinois 1st district election
Democratic Party (United States)
Mary Jane Theis (incumbent)
1,333,122
74.72
Republican Party (United States)
James Gerard Riley
451,039
25.28
1,784,161
100
The court has seven seats total separated into five districts. The first district contains three seats (making it a multi-member district), while other four districts are single-member districts. Justices hold ten year terms.
Retention elections
To be retained, judges were required to have 60% of their vote be "yes".
District IncumbentVoteGE2012Tot_637565023638040551 https://www.elections.il.gov/DocDisplay.aspx?doc=Downloads/ElectionOperations/VoteTotals/2012/ByCandidate/GE2012Tot.xls State of Illinois 13 May 2021 2012CiteParty Name In office since Previous years elected/retainedYes(Retain)No(Remove)3rdRepublicanRita B. Garman February 1, 2001 2002 (elected) 389,891(82.81%) 80,929(17.19%) Judicial candidates Anderson, Glenn endorsed October 30, 1998 Charleston Times-Courier NewsBankRita Garman https://ballotpedia.org/Rita_Garman Ballotpedia 13 May 2021 en
Illinois Appellate Court
Illinois Appellate Court justices hold ten-year terms.
1st district (Cahill vacancy)
A vacancy was created by the death of Robert Cahill.Robert Cahill (Illinois) https://ballotpedia.org/Robert_Cahill_(Illinois) Ballotpedia 13 May 2021 en Matthias William Delort was elected to fill the judgeship.Mathias W. Delort https://ballotpedia.org/Mathias_W._Delort Ballotpedia 13 May 2021 en This was a regular election, as Cahill's term would have ended in 2012.
Democratic primary
Candidates
Matthias William Delort, Cook County Circuit Court judge
Mary Brigid Hayes, member of the Village of La Grange Park Police CommissionMary Brigid Hayes -- 1st Appellate - Cahill Vacancy -- Chicago Tribune editorial board questionnaire http://primaries2012.elections.chicagotribune.com/editorial/mary-brigid-hayes/index.html primaries2012.elections.chicagotribune.com Chicago Tribune 13 May 2021 2012
Kay Marie Hanlon, Northfield Township trusteeKay Marie Hanlon -- 1st Appellate - Cahill Vacancy -- Chicago Tribune editorial board questionnaire http://primaries2012.elections.chicagotribune.com/editorial/kay-marie-hanlon/index.html primaries2012.elections.chicagotribune.com Chicago Tribune 13 May 2021 2012
Pamela E. Hill-Veal, Cook County Circuit Court judgePamela Hill-Veal https://ballotpedia.org/Pamela_Hill-Veal Ballotpedia 13 May 2021 en
James Michael McGing, 1992 Democratic nominee for Illinois State Senate 7th districtJames Michael McGing -- 1st Appellate - Cahill Vacancy -- Chicago Tribune editorial board questionnaire http://primaries2012.elections.chicagotribune.com/editorial/james-michael-mcging/index.html primaries2012.elections.chicagotribune.com Chicago Tribune 13 May 2021 2012State of Illinois official vote cast at the general election .. https://archive.org/details/stateofillinois1992illi/mode/2up Illinois State Board of Elections 7 April 2020
Laura Marie Sullivan, Cook County Circuit Court judgeLaura Sullivan https://ballotpedia.org/Laura_Sullivan Ballotpedia 13 May 2021 en
Results
Illinois Appellate Court 1st district (Cahill vacancy) Democratic primary
Democratic Party (United States)
Matthias William Delort
90,855
24.82
Democratic Party (United States)
Pamela E. Hill-Veal
83,463
22.80
Democratic Party (United States)
Laura Marie Sullivan
65,293
17.84
Democratic Party (United States)
Mary Brigid Hayes
57,909
15.82
Democratic Party (United States)
James Michael McGing
34,353
9.38
Democratic Party (United States)
Kay Marie Hanlon
34,215
9.35
366,088
100
Republican primary
No candidates ran in the primary for the Republican nomination.
General election
Illinois Appellate Court 1st district (Cahill vacancy) election
Democratic Party (United States)
Matthias William Delort
1,381,611
100
1,381,611
100
1st district (Coleman vacancy)
A vacancy was created when Sharon Johnson Coleman stepped down in order to accept a position on the United States District Court for the Northern District of Illinois.Nathaniel R. Howse https://ballotpedia.org/Nathaniel_R._Howse Ballotpedia 13 May 2021 enSharon Coleman https://ballotpedia.org/Sharon_Coleman Ballotpedia 13 May 2021 en Nathaniel Roosevelt Howse, Jr. was elected to fill the judgeship. Before being elected to this judgeship, Howse had already been serving on the Appellate Court, having been appointed to a different 1st district judgeship in August 2009, after the retirement of Denise M. O'Malley.M.R.1062 https://courts.illinois.gov/supremecourt/Announce/2009/072709.pdf State of Illinois Supreme Court 13 May 2021 11 May 2009 This was a regular election, as Coleman's term would have ended in 2012.
Democratic primary
Illinois Appellate Court 1st district (Coleman vacancy) Democratic primary
Democratic Party (United States)
Nathaniel Roosevelt Howse, Jr.
242,772
100
242,772
100
Republican primary
No candidates ran in the primary for the Republican nomination.
General election
Illinois Appellate Court 1st district (Coleman vacancy) election
Democratic Party (United States)
Nathaniel Roosevelt Howse, Jr.
1,334,521
100
1,334,521
100
1st district (Gallagher vacancy)
A vacancy was created when Michael Gallagher retired.P. Scott Neville https://ballotpedia.org/P._Scott_Neville Ballotpedia 13 May 2021 enMichael Gallagher https://ballotpedia.org/Michael_Gallagher_(Illinois) Ballotpedia 13 May 2021 en P. Scott Neville Jr. was elected to fill the judgeship. Before being elected to this judgeship, Neville had already been serving on the Appellate Court, having been served as an appointed member of the first district since 2004.Appellate Court gets Hartigan replacement June 11, 2004 Chicago Tribune May 10, 2020 https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/ct-xpm-2004-05-25-0405250325-story.html
Democratic primary
Candidates
P. Scott Neville Jr., Illinois Appellate Court judge
Marguerite Quinn, Cook County Circuit Court judgeMarguerite Quinn: Candidate Profile https://www.dailyherald.com/article/20120131/submitted/301319581/ Daily Herald 13 May 2021 31 January 2012
Patrick J. Sherlock, Cook County Circuit Court judgePatrick J. Sherlock https://ballotpedia.org/Patrick_J._Sherlock Ballotpedia 13 May 2021 en
Results
Illinois Appellate Court 1st district (Gallagher vacancy) Democratic primary
Democratic Party (United States)
P. Scott Neville, Jr.
159,170
44.30
Democratic Party (United States)
Marguerite Quinn
119,865
33.36
Democratic Party (United States)
Patrick J. Sherlock
80,256
22.34
359,291
100
Republican primary
No candidates ran in the primary for the Republican nomination.
General election
Illinois Appellate Court 1st district (Gallagher vacancy) election
Democratic Party (United States)
P. Scott Neville, Jr.
1,306,485
100
1,306,485
100
1st district (O'Brien vacancy)
A vacancy was created when Sheila O'Brien retired in 2011.Jesse G. Reyes https://ballotpedia.org/Jesse_G._Reyes Ballotpedia 29 May 2021 enSheila O'Brien https://ballotpedia.org/Sheila_O%27Brien Ballotpedia 29 May 2021 en Jesse G. Reyes was elected to fill the judgeship.
Democratic primary
Candidates
William Stewart Boyd, Cook County Circuit Court judgeWilliam Stewart Boyd -- 1st Appellate - O'Brien Vacancy -- Chicago Tribune editorial board questionnaire http://primaries2012.elections.chicagotribune.com/editorial/william-stewart-boyd/index.html primaries2012.elections.chicagotribune.com Chicago Tribune 29 May 2021
Ellen L. Flannigan, Cook County Circuit Court judgeEllen L. Flannigan -- 1st Appellate - O'Brien Vacancy -- Chicago Tribune editorial board questionnaire http://primaries2012.elections.chicagotribune.com/editorial/ellen-l-flannigan/index.html primaries2012.elections.chicagotribune.com Chicago Tribune 29 May 2021
Rodolfo "Rudy" Garcia, Illinois Appellate Court judgeRodolfo (Rudy) Garcia -- 1st Appellate - O'Brien Vacancy -- Chicago Tribune editorial board questionnaire http://primaries2012.elections.chicagotribune.com/editorial/rodolfo-rudy-garcia/index.html primaries2012.elections.chicagotribune.com Chicago Tribune 29 May 2021
Jesse G. Reyes, Cook County Circuit Court judgeJudge Jesse G. Reyes for Illinois First District Appellate Court in Illinois https://trellis.law/judge/jesse.g.reyes trellis.law Trellis 29 May 2021 en
Don R. Sampen, former Illinois assistant attorney generalDon R. Sampen -- 1st Appellate - O'Brien Vacancy -- Chicago Tribune editorial board questionnaire http://primaries2012.elections.chicagotribune.com/editorial/don-r-sampen/index.html primaries2012.elections.chicagotribune.com Chicago Tribune 29 May 2021
Results
Illinois Appellate Court 1st district (O'Brien vacancy) Democratic primary
Democratic Party (United States)
Jesse G. Reyes
120,390
33.04
Democratic Party (United States)
William Stewart Boyd
93,912
25.77
Democratic Party (United States)
Ellen L. Flannigan
80,668
22.14
Democratic Party (United States)
Rodolfo "Rudy" Garcia
45,539
12.5
Democratic Party (United States)
Don R. Sampen
23,873
6.55
364,382
100
Republican primary
No candidates ran in the primary for the Republican nomination.
General election
Illinois Appellate Court 1st district (O'Brien vacancy) election
Democratic Party (United States)
Jesse G. Reyes
1,317,266
100
1,317,266
100
1st district (Theis vacancy)
A vacancy was created when Mary Jane Theis was appointed to the Illinois Supreme Court in 2010.Mary Jane Theis https://ballotpedia.org/Mary_Jane_Theis Ballotpedia 29 May 2021 en Maureen Connors, who had been appointed in October 2010 to fill the judgeship until a permanent occupant would be elected in 2012, was elected to permanently fill the judgeship.Maureen Connors https://ballotpedia.org/Maureen_Connors Ballotpedia 29 May 2021 en
Democratic primary
Candidates
Maureen Connors, incumbent occupant of the judgeship
Results
Illinois Appellate Court 1st district (Theis vacancy) Democratic primary
Democratic Party (United States)
Maureen Elizabeth Connors (incumbent)
325,268
100
325,268
100
Republican primary
No candidates ran in the primary for the Republican nomination.
General election
Illinois Appellate Court 1st district (Theis vacancy) election
Democratic Party (United States)
Maureen Elizabeth Connors (incumbent)
1,316,225
100
1,316,225
100
1st district (Tully vacancy)
A vacancy was created when John Tully retired on December 31, 2009.John Tully https://ballotpedia.org/John_Tully Ballotpedia 29 May 2021 enTerrence J. Lavin https://ballotpedia.org/Terrence_J._Lavin Ballotpedia 29 May 2021 en Terrance J. Lavin, who had been appointed on February 1, 2010, to fill the judgeship until a permanent occupant would be elected in 2012, was elected to permanently fill the judgeship.
Democratic primary
Candidates
Terrence J. Lavin, incumbent occupant of the judgeship
Results
Illinois Appellate Court 1st district (Tully vacancy) Democratic primary
Democratic Party (United States)
Terrence J. Lavin (incumbent)
319,241
100
319,241
100
Republican primary
No candidates ran in the primary for the Republican nomination.
General election
Illinois Appellate Court 1st district (Tully vacancy) election
Democratic Party (United States)
Terrence J. Lavin (incumbent)
1,280,939
100
1,280,939
100
2nd district (O'Malley vacancy)
A vacancy was created when Jack O'Malley retired on December 3, 2010.Jack O'Malley (Illinois) https://ballotpedia.org/Jack_O%27Malley_(Illinois) Ballotpedia 29 May 2021 en Joseph Birkett, who had been appointed on fill the judgeship until a permanent occupant would be elected in 2012, was elected to permanently fill the judgeship.Joseph Birkett https://ballotpedia.org/Joseph_Birkett Ballotpedia 29 May 2021 en
Democratic primary
No candidates ran in the primary for the Democratic nomination.
Republican primary
Candidates
Joseph Birkett, incumbent occupant of the judgeship
Results
Illinois Appellate Court 1st district (O'Malley vacancy) Republican primary
Republican Party (United States)
Joe Birkett (incumbent)
259,025
100
259,025
100
General election
Illinois Appellate Court 1st district (O'Malley vacancy) election
Republican Party (United States)
Joe Birkett (incumbent)
946,823
100
946,823
100
4th district (Myerscough vacancy)
A vacancy was created when Sue E. Myerscough left her judgeship in the Illinois Appellate Court's 4th district to become a judge of the United States District Court for the Central District of Illinois in February 2010.Sue Myerscough https://ballotpedia.org/Sue_Myerscough Ballotpedia 29 May 2021 en Carol Pope was elected to fill the judgeship.Carol Pope https://ballotpedia.org/Carol_Pope Ballotpedia 29 May 2021 en Before being elected to this judgeship, Pope had already been serving on the Illinois Appellate Court's, having been appointed to a different 4th district judgeship in December 2008.
Democratic primary
No candidates ran in the primary for the Democratic nomination.
Republican primary
Candidates
Carol Pope, Illinois Appellate Court judge
Results
Illinois Appellate Court 1st district (Myerscough vacancy) Republican primary
Republican Party (United States)
Carol Pope
115,826
100
115,826
100
General election
Illinois Appellate Court 1st district (Myerscough vacancy) election
Republican Party (United States)
Carol Pope
428,665
100
428,665
100
5th district (Donovan vacancy)
A vacancy was created when James Donovan retired on December 2, 2012.James Donovan https://ballotpedia.org/James_Donovan Ballotpedia 29 May 2021 en Judy Cates was elected to fill the judgeship.Judy Cates https://ballotpedia.org/Judy_Cates Ballotpedia 29 May 2021 en
Democratic primary
Candidates
Judy Cates, attorney and former St. Clair County state's attorney
Results
Illinois Appellate Court 1st district (Donovan vacancy) Democratic primary
Democratic Party (United States)
Judy Cates
52,050
100
52,050
100
Republican primary
Candidates
Stephen P. McGlynn, Illinois 20th Judicial Circuit judge and former Illinois Appellate Court judgeStephen P. McGlynn https://ballotpedia.org/Stephen_P._McGlynn Ballotpedia 29 May 2021 en
Results
Illinois Appellate Court 1st district (Donovan vacancy) Republican primary
Republican Party (United States)
Stephen McGlynn
79,925
100
79,925
100
General election
Illinois Appellate Court 1st district (Donovan vacancy) election
Democratic Party (United States)
Judy Cates
283,926
52.09
Republican Party (United States)
Stephen McGlynn
261,170
47.91
545,096
100
Retention elections
To be retained, judges were required to have 60% of their vote be "yes".
District IncumbentVoteCiteParty Name In office since Previous years elected/retainedYes(Retain)No(Remove) 1stDemocraticJames Fitzgerald Smith December 2, 2002 2002 (elected) 1,058,999(79.81%) 267,955(20.19%)James Fitzgerald Smith https://ballotpedia.org/James_Fitzgerald_Smith Ballotpedia 13 May 2021 en 3rdDemocraticTom M. Lytton December 7, 1992 1992 (elected), 2002 (retained) 521,146 (79.72%) 132,560(20.28%)Tom Lytton https://ballotpedia.org/Tom_Lytton Ballotpedia 13 May 2021 en 3rdRepublicanDaniel L. Schmidt December 2002 2002 (elected) 524,061(80.40%) 127,776 (19.60%)Daniel Schmidt https://ballotpedia.org/Daniel_Schmidt Ballotpedia 13 May 2021 en 4thRepublicanJohn Turner June 2001 2002 (elected) 377,311(82.10%) 82,273(17.90%)John W. Turner https://ballotpedia.org/John_W._Turner Ballotpedia 13 May 2021 en 5thDemocraticMelissa Ann Chapman September 2001 2002 (elected) 370,011(73.76%) 131,601(26.24%)Melissa Chapman https://ballotpedia.org/Melissa_Chapman Ballotpedia 13 May 2021 en
Lower courts
2012 Cook County, Illinois elections#Judicial elections
Lower courts also saw judicial elections.
References
Judicial
2012
Illinois